30,366
edits
Talk:Lugia (Pokémon): Difference between revisions
→Lugia's origins
(Undo revision 3575826 by INTERNETFRIEND (talk) don't delete comments (including your own)) Tag: Undo |
Tiddlywinks (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 231: | Line 231: | ||
:::n.b. the key word in your entry is assumptions. Indeed, I am assuming it's possible that Shudo's order was vague. Which means we cannot know with confidence that Shudo 'created' Lugia. You're assuming Shudo's order was less vague. Cool, great, but in the absence of proof you cannot state with confidence that Shudo 'created' Lugia. I note also you have not addressed the legal – i.e. meaningful – evidence, which, indeed, suggests Shudo categorically did NOT create Lugia. {{Unsigned|INTERNETFRIEND}} | :::n.b. the key word in your entry is assumptions. Indeed, I am assuming it's possible that Shudo's order was vague. Which means we cannot know with confidence that Shudo 'created' Lugia. You're assuming Shudo's order was less vague. Cool, great, but in the absence of proof you cannot state with confidence that Shudo 'created' Lugia. I note also you have not addressed the legal – i.e. meaningful – evidence, which, indeed, suggests Shudo categorically did NOT create Lugia. {{Unsigned|INTERNETFRIEND}} | ||
::::Insofar as any question of respect, why is benefit of doubt vis a vis respect granted to someone who is very unlikely to have created Lugia, and none to any of Ken Sugimori, Motofumi Fujiwara, Shigeki Morimoto, Atsuko Nishida, Hironobu Yoshida, Muneo Saito, Satoshi Oota, and Rena Yoshikawa, one of which any sober analysis will conclude actually created Lugia? {{Unsigned|INTERNETFRIEND}} | ::::Insofar as any question of respect, why is benefit of doubt vis a vis respect granted to someone who is very unlikely to have created Lugia, and none to any of Ken Sugimori, Motofumi Fujiwara, Shigeki Morimoto, Atsuko Nishida, Hironobu Yoshida, Muneo Saito, Satoshi Oota, and Rena Yoshikawa, one of which any sober analysis will conclude actually created Lugia? {{Unsigned|INTERNETFRIEND}} | ||
:::::Your "analysis" is on one hand just guessing (saying anyone "actually" created Lugia is naked guessing) and on the other conflation (you keep hammering on the point that he didn't draw it, like drawing is the only valid kind of "creation", and it absolutely isn't). I'm not assuming Shudo's order was less vague, I'm trusting that when he said he created Lugia, he meant just that, and he didn't mean he "requested it vaguely" which would've been worded very differently. This isn't assumption, this is reasonable communication. | |||
:::::It's simply not your place to say he's "unlikely". He said he created it. [http://www.style.fm/as/05_column/shudo206.shtml 僕が考えたポケモン], "a Pokemon I came up with". (This is also in the [http://lavacutcontent.com/takeshi-shudo-ending-pokemon/ Lava Cut Content article], it handily says "create".) In the absence of explicit refutation, it is nothing short of disrespect to insist his word is false. | |||
:::::To try to be clear here: I'm not saying he drew any art of Lugia. But he said 僕が考えた, so we will credit him with the originating idea. [[User:Tiddlywinks|Tiddlywinks]] ([[User talk:Tiddlywinks|talk]]) 04:05, 25 September 2022 (UTC) | |||