editlock-exempt
28,544
edits
Bulbapedia talk:James/Gardenia poll: Difference between revisions
Bulbapedia talk:James/Gardenia poll (view source)
Revision as of 00:15, 7 August 2012
, 7 August 2012this poll was a mess
Fabu-Vinny (talk | contribs) |
(this poll was a mess) |
||
| (13 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown) | |||
| Line 2: | Line 2: | ||
:I just hope enough people see this. But as of now, James is taking the lead. We'll see what happens at the end of the week. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 03:30, 8 October 2007 (UTC) | :I just hope enough people see this. But as of now, James is taking the lead. We'll see what happens at the end of the week. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 03:30, 8 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
::Actually, Beedrill ''has'' been seen again. The whole reason it was under Casey's name in the first place is that it is one of her main three Pokémon. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 01:44, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ::Actually, Beedrill ''has'' been seen again. The whole reason it was under Casey's name in the first place is that it is one of her main three Pokémon. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 01:44, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
:::Just why do you think it should be at "James's Cacnea"? James doesn't even have a Cacnea. Gardenia has a Cacnea. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> | :::Just why do you think it should be at "James's Cacnea"? James doesn't even have a Cacnea. Gardenia has a Cacnea. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> 01:48, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
::::Of course he has a Cacnea! He has a Cacnea from [[AG006]] all the way through to to [[DP054]]. The fact that a plot device is coming along to take said Cacnea away next month does not change that. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 02:24, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ::::Of course he has a Cacnea! He has a Cacnea from [[AG006]] all the way through to to [[DP054]]. The fact that a plot device is coming along to take said Cacnea away next month does not change that. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 02:24, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
:::::He '''did''' have a Cacnea, but now he doesn't because he gave it to Gardenia. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> | :::::He '''did''' have a Cacnea, but now he doesn't because he gave it to Gardenia. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> 20:41, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
:::::Ah, don't know where my mind went when I said Beedrill hadn't been seen again. And some more reasons why I believe it should be located at James's Cacnea: We don't call [[Misty's Horsea]] and [[Misty's Starmie]] Horsea (Cerulean Gym) and Starmie (Cerulean Gym). We didn't rename Brock's Steelix, Crobat and Geodude to reflect the fact that he gave them to Forrest, we didn't rename James's Victreebel as Magikarp salesman's Victreebel, and we didn't rename Ash's Raticate to Gentleman's Raticate. But the most important reason is that it is a '''future event'''. Doesn't anybody remember [[EP091|a certain episode]] where everybody thought Misty's Psyduck would evolve into Golduck? --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] <sup>[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]</sup> 05:23, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | :::::Ah, don't know where my mind went when I said Beedrill hadn't been seen again. And some more reasons why I believe it should be located at James's Cacnea: We don't call [[Misty's Horsea]] and [[Misty's Starmie]] Horsea (Cerulean Gym) and Starmie (Cerulean Gym). We didn't rename Brock's Steelix, Crobat and Geodude to reflect the fact that he gave them to Forrest, we didn't rename James's Victreebel as Magikarp salesman's Victreebel, and we didn't rename Ash's Raticate to Gentleman's Raticate. But the most important reason is that it is a '''future event'''. Doesn't anybody remember [[EP091|a certain episode]] where everybody thought Misty's Psyduck would evolve into Golduck? --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] <sup>[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]</sup> 05:23, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
:Not sure about the official part, but that weightings nonsense has been reverted. Only sysops have the ability to weigh the poll, and this poll is not that important to be weighted. The only poll I can think of that was weighted was the one about the ads, and that's because it was such an important issue. And there, the one who made that decision was Zhen Lin, the editor-in-chief. --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] <sup>[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]</sup> 21:16, 9 October 2007 (UTC) | :Not sure about the official part, but that weightings nonsense has been reverted. Only sysops have the ability to weigh the poll, and this poll is not that important to be weighted. The only poll I can think of that was weighted was the one about the ads, and that's because it was such an important issue. And there, the one who made that decision was Zhen Lin, the editor-in-chief. --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] <sup>[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]</sup> 21:16, 9 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
::The weightings have still ended up at 11 to 16 in favour of James anyway. :p --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 01:46, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ::The weightings have still ended up at 11 to 16 in favour of James anyway. :p --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 01:46, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
:::But losing by 5 is better than losing by 6. It's a lot easier to catch up. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> | :::But losing by 5 is better than losing by 6. It's a lot easier to catch up. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> 01:48, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
::::Yes, but directly attempting to manipulate the results undermines the validity of this poll. That's why I'm creating this next section... --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 02:00, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ::::Yes, but directly attempting to manipulate the results undermines the validity of this poll. That's why I'm creating this next section... --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 02:00, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
:::::I wasn't trying to manipulate the results. I simply felt that bigger contributors should have their vote count more. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> | :::::I wasn't trying to manipulate the results. I simply felt that bigger contributors should have their vote count more. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> 23:05, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
::::::It's not the quantity, but the quality of your edits that matters. --[[User:DarkfireTaimatsu|DarkfireTaimatsu]] 21:25, 13 October 2007 (UTC) | ::::::It's not the quantity, but the quality of your edits that matters. --[[User:DarkfireTaimatsu|DarkfireTaimatsu]] 21:25, 13 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
| Line 23: | Line 23: | ||
::Taking another cue from Wikipedia, they title things by their most common name. There have been countless debates there over article names, often solved by Google searches. Even after the episode airs in the US, Cacnea will likely be called "James's Cacnea" by the majority of the community. Therefore, the article should be titled to reflect this. [[User:Zurqoxn|Zurqoxn]] 18:07, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ::Taking another cue from Wikipedia, they title things by their most common name. There have been countless debates there over article names, often solved by Google searches. Even after the episode airs in the US, Cacnea will likely be called "James's Cacnea" by the majority of the community. Therefore, the article should be titled to reflect this. [[User:Zurqoxn|Zurqoxn]] 18:07, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
:::James doesn't own a Cacnea. Gardenia owns a Cacnea. We shouldn't have an article about a Pokémon that doesn't exist. Since James gave it to Gardenia, there is no such Pokémon as "James's Cacnea," but there '''is''' a Pokémon called "Gardenia's Cacnea." We should call it by the name of the person who actually owns it, which is Gardenia. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> | :::James doesn't own a Cacnea. Gardenia owns a Cacnea. We shouldn't have an article about a Pokémon that doesn't exist. Since James gave it to Gardenia, there is no such Pokémon as "James's Cacnea," but there '''is''' a Pokémon called "Gardenia's Cacnea." We should call it by the name of the person who actually owns it, which is Gardenia. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]</sup> 20:21, 12 October 2007 (UTC) | ||
(It only makes sense, otherwise Bulbapedia will be a mess and people that visit will say things like, "I thought it was Gardenia's Cacnea now?". And eventually all COTDs will have a page for their Pokémon, so why make things unorganised?) <big> | (It only makes sense, otherwise Bulbapedia will be a mess and people that visit will say things like, "I thought it was Gardenia's Cacnea now?". And eventually all COTDs will have a page for their Pokémon, so why make things unorganised?) <big><sub>[[User:Tesh|<span style="color:#F05030;">'''TESH'''</span>]]</sub><sub>[[User Talk:Tesh|<span style="color:#5C8CFA;">'''TALK'''</span>]]</sub> <sub>[[User:Tesh/Other|<span style="color:#EEC226;">'''FUN'''</span>]]</sub></big> 16:44, 17 November 2007 (UTC) PS I forgot about | ||
what it said, I got carried away... XD! | what it said, I got carried away... XD! | ||
Think of Sabrina's Haunter, its the same thing, I think it should be Gardenia's Cacnea! | Think of Sabrina's Haunter, its the same thing, I think it should be Gardenia's Cacnea! [[User:Kpokefan|<span style="color:#003366;">K</span>]][[User Talk:Kpokefan|<span style="color:#003366;">P</span>]][[Darkrai (Pokémon)|<span style="color:#003366;">F</span>]][[User:Kpokefan/Cal|<span style="color:#003366;">☆</span>]] 17:49, 17 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
But you're talking about a Pokémon that Ash DID NOT officially capture and was there for less than 2 episodes. James actually captured his Cacnea and it stayed on his team for 260 episodes. I think that's a big difference. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 00:31, 18 November 2007 (UTC) | But you're talking about a Pokémon that Ash DID NOT officially capture and was there for less than 2 episodes. James actually captured his Cacnea and it stayed on his team for 260 episodes. I think that's a big difference. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 00:31, 18 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
| Line 34: | Line 34: | ||
::Exactly. Surely you people don't believe that we should call it "Liza's Charizard"? If it were one of Ash's Pokémon then we wouldn't be having this debate. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 02:58, 18 November 2007 (UTC) | ::Exactly. Surely you people don't believe that we should call it "Liza's Charizard"? If it were one of Ash's Pokémon then we wouldn't be having this debate. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 02:58, 18 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
But Ash didn't officially release Charizard, he put it in training. Well you have a point with the Raticate... I'm just thinking of peeople that visit Bulbapedia, not just the Users... <big> | But Ash didn't officially release Charizard, he put it in training. Well you have a point with the Raticate... I'm just thinking of peeople that visit Bulbapedia, not just the Users... <big><sub>[[User:Tesh|<span style="color:#F05030;">'''TESH'''</span>]]</sub><sub>[[User Talk:Tesh|<span style="color:#5C8CFA;">'''TALK'''</span>]]</sub> <sub>[[User:Tesh/Other|<span style="color:#EEC226;">'''FUN'''</span>]]</sub></big> 13:56, 18 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
:Again, I'll reiterate the points that I have been making all along. The reason we call Ash's Haunter [[Sabrina's Haunter]] is because he never ''technically'' owned it. Now, if he had captured it in a Poké Ball or actually used it ''in battle'' (which he didn't do) I would have it moved back to Ash's Haunter. As for [[Brock's Vulpix]], although he said he never felt that it was his, it was. Susie is nothing more than a [[character of the day]] who happened to appear in one more episode. Bulbapedia does not have articles for Pokémon belonging to characters of the day, and Susie is no exception. This is the same reason we do not call [[Jessie's Lickitung]] Benny's Lickitung. He is a minor character of the day who never appeared again, or was made reference to. | :Again, I'll reiterate the points that I have been making all along. The reason we call Ash's Haunter [[Sabrina's Haunter]] is because he never ''technically'' owned it. Now, if he had captured it in a Poké Ball or actually used it ''in battle'' (which he didn't do) I would have it moved back to Ash's Haunter. As for [[Brock's Vulpix]], although he said he never felt that it was his, it was. Susie is nothing more than a [[character of the day]] who happened to appear in one more episode. Bulbapedia does not have articles for Pokémon belonging to characters of the day, and Susie is no exception. This is the same reason we do not call [[Jessie's Lickitung]] Benny's Lickitung. He is a minor character of the day who never appeared again, or was made reference to. | ||
| Line 40: | Line 40: | ||
:Now, the major difference between calling it Sabrina's Haunter and calling this Gardenia's Cacnea is because James actually legitimately caught Cacnea, and used it in battle countless times. Can the same be said for Haunter? No. In fact, most fans of the TV show probably don't even realize that Ash even used a Haunter. Just like how most fans are more likely to remember Brock than Susie, or James than Gardenia, or Jessie than Benny. Honestly, I don't see why people are getting so worked up about this. --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] <sup>[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]</sup> 02:21, 19 November 2007 (UTC) | :Now, the major difference between calling it Sabrina's Haunter and calling this Gardenia's Cacnea is because James actually legitimately caught Cacnea, and used it in battle countless times. Can the same be said for Haunter? No. In fact, most fans of the TV show probably don't even realize that Ash even used a Haunter. Just like how most fans are more likely to remember Brock than Susie, or James than Gardenia, or Jessie than Benny. Honestly, I don't see why people are getting so worked up about this. --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] <sup>[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]</sup> 02:21, 19 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
Good Point. By the way, I'm not getting worked up, I just thought it should be changed to the current owner and not the previous. Meh, I don't care anymore. (Who knows, Gardania might return) XD <big> | Good Point. By the way, I'm not getting worked up, I just thought it should be changed to the current owner and not the previous. Meh, I don't care anymore. (Who knows, Gardania might return) XD <big><sub>[[User:Tesh|<span style="color:#F05030;">'''TESH'''</span>]]</sub><sub>[[User Talk:Tesh|<span style="color:#5C8CFA;">'''TALK'''</span>]]</sub> <sub>[[User:Tesh/Other|<span style="color:#EEC226;">'''FUN'''</span>]]</sub></big> 16:18, 19 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
:If Gardenia becomes a recurring character after this point, then there will be grounds to consider this issue. Unless that happens, Cacnea goes under James. Simple as that. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 02:00, 22 November 2007 (UTC) | :If Gardenia becomes a recurring character after this point, then there will be grounds to consider this issue. Unless that happens, Cacnea goes under James. Simple as that. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 02:00, 22 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
| Line 46: | Line 46: | ||
== Enough of this edit war! == | == Enough of this edit war! == | ||
I've had enough of this edit war over whose side the Poké Ball transfer belongs on. My honest 2¢: It's best to view that event from both angles. He could have outright given it away, similar to how {{TP|Casey|Beedrill}} went from [[Ash]] to | I've had enough of this edit war over whose side the Poké Ball transfer belongs on. My honest 2¢: It's best to view that event from both angles. He could have outright given it away, similar to how {{TP|Casey|Beedrill}} went from [[Ash]] to {{an|Casey}}. On the flip side, he may have had intention to get it back someday at the time of the transfer, similar to how {{TP|Ash|Primeape}} went from Ash to [[Anthony (Kanto)|Anthony]]. Believe me, it can be seen as evidence either way, and hence I've included both phrases used in this edit war to reflect such. | ||
(For the record, the cent sign is Alt-155 or Alt-0162 on Windows.) --[[User:Shiningpikablu252|Shiningpikablu252]] 21:23, 21 November 2007 (UTC) | (For the record, the cent sign is Alt-155 or Alt-0162 on Windows.) --[[User:Shiningpikablu252|Shiningpikablu252]] 21:23, 21 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
| Line 54: | Line 54: | ||
Dude. What the crap. | Dude. What the crap. | ||
I say we need a closing date for this. It's been open for a while, it's a stupid poll anyway, it's 17-5 (Kinda big difference.) and.. yeah. I say we close this. | I say we need a closing date for this. It's been open for a while, it's a stupid poll anyway, it's 17-5 (Kinda big difference.) and.. yeah. I say we close this. [[User:TinaTheKirlia|<span style="color:#E75480;">T</span><span style="color:#FF69B4;">i</span><span style="color:#F6ADC6;">n</span><span style="color:#FFC0CB;">a</span>]]<sup>[[User:TinaTheKirlia/Sandbox|<span style="color:#FFC0CB;">☆</span>]][[User:TinaTheKirlia/Favorites|<span style="color:#F6ADC6;">♥</span>]][[User talk:TinaTheKirlia|<span style="color:#FF69B4;">♫</span>]]<span class="plainlinks">[http://freewebs.com/thepixelcafe <span style="color:#FF7BBD;">δ</span>]</span></sup> 22:25, 21 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
: I say at least wait until the episode airs in English. [[User:Zurqoxn|Zurqoxn]] 23:53, 21 November 2007 (UTC) | : I say at least wait until the episode airs in English. [[User:Zurqoxn|Zurqoxn]] 23:53, 21 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
::That is far too long. I say we should close the poll now. Consensus here and beyond the poll is that the Pokémon of main characters go under the main character's name even after leaving. There is no need to keep it open at all. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 01:57, 22 November 2007 (UTC) | ::That is far too long. I say we should close the poll now. Consensus here and beyond the poll is that the Pokémon of main characters go under the main character's name even after leaving. There is no need to keep it open at all. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 01:57, 22 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
::::Consensus means that everyone agrees. I don't agree, so it isn't consensus. --[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<font color="black"><small>S</small><sup>h</sup><small>i</small><sub>n</sub><small>y</small> <sup>N</sup><small>o</small><sub>c</sub><small>t</small><sup>o</sup><small>w</small><sub>l</sub></font>]] 19:32, 15 June 2008 (UTC) | |||
:::Why don't you tell that to Shiny Noctowl. He's the reason that we have this problem. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 05:45, 22 November 2007 (UTC) | :::Why don't you tell that to Shiny Noctowl. He's the reason that we have this problem. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 05:45, 22 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
He's practically forgotten all about this already... | He's practically forgotten all about this already... <sc>'''[[User:Optimus35|<span style="color:#000033">A</span><span style="color:#003366">g</span><span style="color:#215670">e</span><span style="color:#006699">n</span><span style="color:#2D6E89">t</span>]] [[User talk:Optimus35|<span style="color:#0066CC">#</span><span style="color:#3D81EE">4</span><span style="color:#66B5FF">4</span><span style="color:#99C9FF">8</span>]]'''</sc> <sup><sc><span class="plainlinks">[http://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/w/index.php?limit=50&title=Special%3AContributions&contribs=user&target=Optimus35&namespace=0&year=&month=-1 <span style="color:#000000;">☆</span>] | [http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qZPMmUEHFIU <span style="color:#FF0000;">♥</span>]</span></sc></sup> 05:50, 22 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
:I don't think he has cause he's still arguing over it. I find it quite funny to say he knows all about the circumstances of James giving Cacnea to Gardenia when he doesn't even watch the original episodes. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 06:41, 25 November 2007 (UTC) | |||
Which is another reason why to close it. The topic is lost, so is the poll. | Which is another reason why to close it. The topic is lost, so is the poll. [[User:TinaTheKirlia|<span style="color:#E75480;">T</span><span style="color:#FF69B4;">i</span><span style="color:#F6ADC6;">n</span><span style="color:#FFC0CB;">a</span>]]<sup>[[User:TinaTheKirlia/Sandbox|<span style="color:#FFC0CB;">☆</span>]][[User:TinaTheKirlia/Favorites|<span style="color:#F6ADC6;">♥</span>]][[User talk:TinaTheKirlia|<span style="color:#FF69B4;">♫</span>]]<span class="plainlinks">[http://freewebs.com/thepixelcafe <span style="color:#FF7BBD;">δ</span>]</span></sup> 21:12, 22 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
::::Fabu-Vinny, "consensus" means that ''everyone'' agrees. As you can see by the poll, everyone doesn't agree. | ::::Fabu-Vinny, "consensus" means that ''everyone'' agrees. As you can see by the poll, everyone doesn't agree. [[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: #221202">S</span><span style="color: #550E01">h</span><span style="color: #880901">i</span><span style="color: #CC0500">n</span><span style="color: #FF0000">y</span>]]<sup>[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: #221202">?</span>]][[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: #FF0000">!</span>]]</sup> 23:23, 22 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
:::::If that was all there is to consensus then we would never get anything sorted. The case for James has the majority agreement and fits in with the results of the wider naming debates. Being stubborn isn't enough to change that. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 03:58, 25 November 2007 (UTC) | :::::If that was all there is to consensus then we would never get anything sorted. The case for James has the majority agreement and fits in with the results of the wider naming debates. Being stubborn isn't enough to change that. --[[User:Fabu-Vinny|FabuVinny]] <sup>[[User talk:Fabu-Vinny|T]]-[[Special:Contributions/Fabu-Vinny|C]]-[[User:Fabu-Vinny/Sandbox|S]]</sup> 03:58, 25 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
:Whew. This mess is finally over. The big message is basically saying this. | |||
<big><big><big><big>'''IT'S GONNA BE JAMES'S FOREVER.'''</big></big></big></big> End of story. No more arguements about this freakin stupid poll. =.= [[User:TinaTheKirlia|<span style="color:#E75480;">T</span><span style="color:#FF69B4;">i</span><span style="color:#F6ADC6;">n</span><span style="color:#FFC0CB;">a</span>]]<sup>[[User:TinaTheKirlia/Sandbox|<span style="color:#FFC0CB;">☆</span>]][[User:TinaTheKirlia/Favorites|<span style="color:#F6ADC6;">♥</span>]][[User talk:TinaTheKirlia|<span style="color:#FF69B4;">♫</span>]]<span class="plainlinks">[http://freewebs.com/thepixelcafe <span style="color:#FF7BBD;">δ</span>]</span></sup> 17:30, 28 November 2007 (UTC) | |||
==Help== | |||
<big><big>'''Someone who can edit this now-protected page please put my name for James'''</big></big>[[User:Pokemaniac102|<span style="color:#EEC226;">'''Poke'''</span><span style="color:#F05030;">'''maniac'''</span><span style="color:#5C8CFA;">'''102'''</span>]] 15:40, 15 December 2007 (UTC) | |||
:Poll's closed. Sorry. --[[User:Shiningpikablu252|Shiningpikablu252]] 15:42, 15 December 2007 (UTC) | |||
k. Who won?[[User:Pokemaniac102|<span style="color:#EEC226;">'''Poke'''</span>]][[User talk:Pokemaniac102|<span style="color:#F05030;">'''maniac'''</span>]][[Special:Contributions/Pokemaniac102|<span style="color:#5C8CFA;">'''102'''</span>]] 16:25, 15 December 2007 (UTC) | |||
:James won, despite {{u|Shiny Noctowl}}'s efforts to try to skew the poll in Gardenia's favor. These efforts include: | |||
:*Trying to weight the poll{{tt|*|The move would have backfired anyway, since three of the users in the bull**** weightings picked James}} | |||
:*Insisting James's Cacnea doesn't exist because of the events of [[DP054]]{{tt|*|We can't just ignore the past!}} | |||
:*Setting no closing date in hopes Gardenia would make a comeback{{tt|*|Fabu-Vinny was the one that closed the poll}} | |||
:*Insisting James giving over the Poké Ball is evidence for Gardenia's side when it was long-standing in the James column{{tt|*|The edit war probably would have gone on until the page was protected if I hadn't decided to look at it from both sides}} | |||
:Of course, as Fabu-Vinny said, if Gardenia does become a recurring character after DP054 (I highly doubt that--****, I wouldn't have anticipated Gardenia reappearing after [[DP037]]) and doesn't give Cacnea back, there might be grounds for renaming the page, but it stays at James as it stands now. --[[User:Shiningpikablu252|Shiningpikablu252]] 17:01, 15 December 2007 (UTC) | |||
== ... == | |||
Why is this still here? Can't it be deleted now? This was going on even before I left! --'''[[User:Theryguy512|<span style="color:#FF7F00">Theryguy</span>]][[User Talk:Theryguy512|<span style="color:#5C8CFA">512</span>]]''' 00:46, 27 February 2009 (UTC) | |||
:It's kept for the purposes of chronicling our past. '''[[User:TTEchidna|<span style="color:#FF0000">''TTE''</span>]][[User talk:TTEchidna|chidna]]''' 03:03, 27 February 2009 (UTC) | |||
::Oh.....That makes sense. Okey dokey! --'''[[User:Theryguy512|<span style="color:#FF7F00">Theryguy</span>]][[User Talk:Theryguy512|<span style="color:#5C8CFA">512</span>]]''' 03:22, 27 February 2009 (UTC) | |||