55,887
edits
Talk:Ash's Pikachu/Featured article candidate/Nomination 1: Difference between revisions
Talk:Ash's Pikachu/Featured article candidate/Nomination 1 (view source)
Revision as of 00:14, 30 August 2008
, 30 August 2008no edit summary
ElectAbuzzzz (talk | contribs) mNo edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
===Support (4)=== | ====Support (4)==== | ||
*I'll go with it. Pikachu's page is at least as good as Ash and the Pikachu to English translations are especially convincing. Only objection is that the main article fizzles a bit towards the end. [[User:Aura-Knight|Aura-Knight]] 16:37, 24 July 2008 (UTC) | *I'll go with it. Pikachu's page is at least as good as Ash and the Pikachu to English translations are especially convincing. Only objection is that the main article fizzles a bit towards the end. [[User:Aura-Knight|Aura-Knight]] 16:37, 24 July 2008 (UTC) | ||
*Hmm... I guess he's right. I certainly like this one better than most other FACs. The only improvements I could suggest are to cut down on trivia by incorporating them into the main article (perhaps we could create a "gender debate" section to help with this?). (EDIT: as of 7/25/08 at 8:00 AST, {{u|Aura-Knight}} has made the changes I suggested, so now I'm more fully behind this.) --[[User:Martonimos|<font color="#008000">Martonimos</font>]]<sub>[[User talk:Martonimos|((<font color="#00FF00">Argh</font>]]|[[Special:Contributions/Martonimos|<font color="#50C878">Blargh</font>))]]</sub> 23:11, 24 July 2008 (UTC) | *Hmm... I guess he's right. I certainly like this one better than most other FACs. The only improvements I could suggest are to cut down on trivia by incorporating them into the main article (perhaps we could create a "gender debate" section to help with this?). (EDIT: as of 7/25/08 at 8:00 AST, {{u|Aura-Knight}} has made the changes I suggested, so now I'm more fully behind this.) --[[User:Martonimos|<font color="#008000">Martonimos</font>]]<sub>[[User talk:Martonimos|((<font color="#00FF00">Argh</font>]]|[[Special:Contributions/Martonimos|<font color="#50C878">Blargh</font>))]]</sub> 23:11, 24 July 2008 (UTC) | ||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
*Yes, THis article features one of the main chracters of the show. [[User:Elbutler|Elbutler]] 11:38, 15 August 2008 (UTC) | *Yes, THis article features one of the main chracters of the show. [[User:Elbutler|Elbutler]] 11:38, 15 August 2008 (UTC) | ||
===Object (3)=== | ====Object (3)==== | ||
*I don't think this choice is very original and it isn't what I would say is one of the best, and I think that there are more note-worthy articles out there. ''[[User:Moldy orange|<sup style="color:#4B5320;">'''Moldy'''</sup>]][[User talk:Moldy orange|<sub style="color:#ED9121;">'''Orange'''</sub>]]'' 23:52, 24 July 2008 (UTC) | *I don't think this choice is very original and it isn't what I would say is one of the best, and I think that there are more note-worthy articles out there. ''[[User:Moldy orange|<sup style="color:#4B5320;">'''Moldy'''</sup>]][[User talk:Moldy orange|<sub style="color:#ED9121;">'''Orange'''</sub>]]'' 23:52, 24 July 2008 (UTC) | ||
*I concur, its nomination is bunk[[User:Darth Cookie Monster|<span style="color:##800000;">DCM</span>]] 13:46, 28 July 2008 (UTC) | *I concur, its nomination is bunk[[User:Darth Cookie Monster|<span style="color:##800000;">DCM</span>]] 13:46, 28 July 2008 (UTC) | ||
*We can do better. '''[[User:Optimus35|<span class="explain" title="Optimus35"><sc>Θρtιmαtum♏</sc></span>]]<sub>[[User talk:Ph34r4ever|Talk]]|[[User:Optimus35/sig/Pikachu|Links]]</sub>''11:44 15 Aug 2008''''' | *We can do better. '''[[User:Optimus35|<span class="explain" title="Optimus35"><sc>Θρtιmαtum♏</sc></span>]]<sub>[[User talk:Ph34r4ever|Talk]]|[[User:Optimus35/sig/Pikachu|Links]]</sub>''11:44 15 Aug 2008''''' | ||
===Other comments=== | ====Other comments==== | ||
In response to your comment Moldy Orange, most of those other articles are already nominated. Pikachu is probably the best anime Pokémon page. [[User:Aura-Knight|Aura-Knight]] 13:41, 28 July 2008 (UTC) | In response to your comment Moldy Orange, most of those other articles are already nominated. Pikachu is probably the best anime Pokémon page. [[User:Aura-Knight|Aura-Knight]] 13:41, 28 July 2008 (UTC) | ||
:A lot of people will ignore this because it's a main character page, but unlike {{Ash}}, I believe this one actually has merit. The "language" section especially shows a great deal of research, and not the level you'd expect from some fangirl. I just want to make clear that we're not necessarily supporting this because "i <3 pikachu", although some of us might, but because we think it's a well-thought out article. I mean, come on, guys; I ''hate'' the anime and everything associated with it. --[[User:Martonimos|<font color="#008000">Martonimos</font>]]<sub>[[User talk:Martonimos|((<font color="#00FF00">Argh</font>]]|[[Special:Contributions/Martonimos|<font color="#50C878">Blargh</font>))]]</sub> 18:39, 13 August 2008 (UTC) | :A lot of people will ignore this because it's a main character page, but unlike {{Ash}}, I believe this one actually has merit. The "language" section especially shows a great deal of research, and not the level you'd expect from some fangirl. I just want to make clear that we're not necessarily supporting this because "i <3 pikachu", although some of us might, but because we think it's a well-thought out article. I mean, come on, guys; I ''hate'' the anime and everything associated with it. --[[User:Martonimos|<font color="#008000">Martonimos</font>]]<sub>[[User talk:Martonimos|((<font color="#00FF00">Argh</font>]]|[[Special:Contributions/Martonimos|<font color="#50C878">Blargh</font>))]]</sub> 18:39, 13 August 2008 (UTC) | ||