14,032
edits
Bulbapedia talk:James/Gardenia poll: Difference between revisions
Bulbapedia talk:James/Gardenia poll (view source)
Revision as of 02:21, 19 November 2007
, 19 November 2007→Let's discuss this
| Line 35: | Line 35: | ||
But Ash didn't officially release Charizard, he put it in training. Well you have a point with the Raticate... I'm just thinking of peeople that visit Bulbapedia, not just the Users... <big>[[Image:Ani137MS.gif]]<sub>[[User:Tesh|<span style="color:#F05030;">'''TESH'''</span>]]</sub>[[Image:Ani233MS.gif]]<sub>[[User Talk:Tesh|<span style="color:#5C8CFA;">'''TALK'''</span>]]</sub> [[Image:Ani474MS.gif]]<sub>[[User:Tesh/Other|<span style="color:#EEC226;">'''FUN'''</span>]]</sub></big> 13:56, 18 November 2007 (UTC) | But Ash didn't officially release Charizard, he put it in training. Well you have a point with the Raticate... I'm just thinking of peeople that visit Bulbapedia, not just the Users... <big>[[Image:Ani137MS.gif]]<sub>[[User:Tesh|<span style="color:#F05030;">'''TESH'''</span>]]</sub>[[Image:Ani233MS.gif]]<sub>[[User Talk:Tesh|<span style="color:#5C8CFA;">'''TALK'''</span>]]</sub> [[Image:Ani474MS.gif]]<sub>[[User:Tesh/Other|<span style="color:#EEC226;">'''FUN'''</span>]]</sub></big> 13:56, 18 November 2007 (UTC) | ||
:Again, I'll reiterate the points that I have been making all along. The reason we call Ash's Haunter [[Sabrina's Haunter]] is because he never ''technically'' owned it. Now, if he had captured it in a Poké Ball or actually used it ''in battle'' (which he didn't do) I would have it moved back to Ash's Haunter. As for [[Brock's Vulpix]], although he said he never felt that it was his, it was. Susie is nothing more than a [[character of the day]] who happened to appear in one more episode. Bulbapedia does not have articles for Pokémon belonging to characters of the day, and Susie is no exception. This is the same reason we do not call [[Jessie's Lickitung]] Benny's Lickitung. He is a minor character of the day who never appeared again, or was made reference to. | |||
:Now, the major difference between calling it Sabrina's Haunter and calling this Gardenia's Cacnea is because James actually legitimately caught Cacnea, and used it in battle countless times. Can the same be said for Haunter? No. In fact, most fans of the TV show probably don't even realize that Ash even used a Haunter. Just like how most fans are more likely to remember Brock than Susie, or James than Gardenia, or Jessie than Benny. Honestly, I don't see why people are getting so worked up about this. --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] <sup>[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]</sup> 02:21, 19 November 2007 (UTC) | |||