Bulbapedia talk:James/Gardenia poll: Difference between revisions

Why was this even moved to begin with? The only articles that I can see that deserve to be moved like this are [[Sabrina's Haunter]] (because Ash only had it for one episode, and it has never been alluded to since that point unlike his other Pokémon), [[Casey's Beedrill]] (again, same reason) and [[Ash's Chimchar]] (because Ash is the main character of the series, whereas Paul is simply a rival). Now, one could argue that since Ash only owned Primeape for five episodes, it should be renamed as Anthony's Primeape. However, unlike Haunter and Beedrill, Primeape ''has'' been referenced to as being Ash's ([[Spurt!]] comes to mind). It's not called Benny's Lickitung because Jessie owned it for longer than he did, and he is an unimportant character of the day, and we do not create articles based on Pokémon belonging to characters of the day. Ash's Chimchar is in sort of a gray area, but I personally am in support of keeping it at that name, at least for now. If something happens (like Paul gets it back, or something) we can always rename that article. But there is absolutely no reason why James's Cacnea should have been renamed to Gardenia's Cacnea. I would switch it back myself right now, but since there's a poll, it would be best to wait and hear what the users of Bulbapedia have to say. --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] ^{[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]} 02:30, 8 October 2007 (UTC)

:I just hope enough people see this.  But as of now, James is taking the lead.  We'll see what happens at the end of the week. --[[Special:Contributions/Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#0005CD;">☆</span>]][[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#15E200;">ケンジ</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#DC0062;">ガール</span>]] 03:30, 8 October 2007 (UTC)