Talk:Rind Island: Difference between revisions

Talk:Rind Island (view source)

Revision as of 09:25, 2 March 2009

530 bytes added , 2 March 2009

m

no edit summary

Platinum

30

edits

Revision as of 16:59, 12 February 2009 (view source) Maxim (talk \| contribs) (→‎Rind, really?: Sorry for late reply. But I DO have proof that Rind and Millsweet is the same island. You should have asked me via talk page.) ← Older edit		Revision as of 09:25, 2 March 2009 (view source) Platinum (talk \| contribs) mNo edit summary Newer edit →
Line 9:		Line 9:

	:Sorry for the late reply (I didn't notice that) but I DO have a proof on this. Here [http://pokesho.com/img_tokusetu/t_map1.gif is Pokesho's map] of Pokemon World. I know that Pokesho is not an official site but his map is exactly the same as the one from DVD, which means that his art copies it. Now compare it with [http://archives.bulbagarden.net/w/upload/5/5a/Orange.jpg The Official Orange Islands Map] and see that Millsweet Island takes the place of タンカン島 (Tankan Shima, which is Rind Island's Japanese name) from Pokesho's map. Which means that Millsweet Island = Tankan Shima. [http://pokeani.com/chara/g_c-orange2.html PokeAni] confirms that Tankan Shima is the island which appeared in the episode with Dr. Quackenpoker. Which means that Tankan Island is the same island as Rind Island and in turn the same island as Millsweet Island. Confusing, isn't it? But I think this proves it. --[[User:Maxim\|Maxim]] 16:59, 12 February 2009 (UTC)		:Sorry for the late reply (I didn't notice that) but I DO have a proof on this. Here [http://pokesho.com/img_tokusetu/t_map1.gif is Pokesho's map] of Pokemon World. I know that Pokesho is not an official site but his map is exactly the same as the one from DVD, which means that his art copies it. Now compare it with [http://archives.bulbagarden.net/w/upload/5/5a/Orange.jpg The Official Orange Islands Map] and see that Millsweet Island takes the place of タンカン島 (Tankan Shima, which is Rind Island's Japanese name) from Pokesho's map. Which means that Millsweet Island = Tankan Shima. [http://pokeani.com/chara/g_c-orange2.html PokeAni] confirms that Tankan Shima is the island which appeared in the episode with Dr. Quackenpoker. Which means that Tankan Island is the same island as Rind Island and in turn the same island as Millsweet Island. Confusing, isn't it? But I think this proves it. --[[User:Maxim\|Maxim]] 16:59, 12 February 2009 (UTC)

			That's circular logic. Unless an official Japanese version of the map can be cited with the location of Tankan Shima, one can just as easily presume they got confused based on this very Bulbapedia article, and not from series canon. (In other words, citing an unofficial source as a point of reference for an area's placement isn't good enough to constitute as legitimate.) We already knew Tankan Shima was Rind Island based on the episode in which Rind Island is featured. - [[User:Platinum\|Platinum]] 09:25, 2 March 2009 (UTC)