56
edits
Talk:RocketShipping: Difference between revisions
no edit summary
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 75: | Line 75: | ||
==new name?== | ==new name?== | ||
should call it 99% cannon shipping prob has the most amount of evidnce {{unsigned|Theultrasheeplord}} | should call it 99% cannon shipping prob has the most amount of evidnce {{unsigned|Theultrasheeplord}} | ||
==Overhaul #2== | |||
This page was substantially overhauled in 2009, since when it has grown organically, free from restraint. However, it is now almost unusable as a wiki page and I have received more than one request on the BMGf Rocketshipping thread for links to "another" page which might more concisely go through shipping hints. | |||
I know it is challenging because there is a huge volume of valid content, but I think we could make the page more reader-friendly simply by restructuring. | |||
For example: | |||
:Intro | |||
:Contents | |||
:1 History | |||
:2 Sects | |||
:3 Evidence | |||
::3.1 Anime evidence | |||
:::3.1.1 Original Series | |||
:::3.1.2 Advanced Generation | |||
:::3.1.3 Diamond and Pearl | |||
:::3.1.4 Best Wishes | |||
:::3.1.5 X&Y | |||
:::3.1.6 Sun and Moon | |||
:::3.1.7 Movies | |||
::3.2 Manga | |||
::3.3 Radio | |||
::3.4 Games | |||
:4 Similarities | |||
:5 Trivia | |||
:6 External links | |||
The major change I am suggesting would remove the idea of Jessie vs James vs shared hints, replacing it with a series-based split. I appreciate this may be controversial, but there is such a lot of unnecessary duplication of information with the original demarcation. Bookmarking the sections instead by series would make it easier for fans to find episodes to watch .etc. | |||
Additionally, within each of the series subsections, I would suggest subheadings of "Present in original" and "Present in other dubs", because there is huge variation between the characterisation of Musashi & Kojirou vs Jessie & James which affects their shipping in a major way. I think it is '''vital''' to provide that context to fans unfamiliar with this background, who might be using this page. | |||
I also think it is time we remove the link to "AntiRocketShipping support" - no other shipping page has or would tolerate this. Pokemopolis' role in the ship's history is already mentioned at the top of the page. | |||
Each section will need significant internal revamps to make them up-to-date, but I think this restructure (or similar, with consensus agreement) is overdue given the size of the page. --[[User:ii kanji|ii kanji]] 18:05, 3 January 2019 (GMT) | |||