Talk:Proton: Difference between revisions

Talk:Proton (view source)

Revision as of 22:55, 4 April 2010

1,493 bytes added , 4 April 2010

→‎Whether or not Proton and Petrel existed: new section

Teamrocketspy621

22

edits

@@ Line 26: / Line 26: @@
 There's an error in [[Lance (Team Rocket)#Second battle|this section of the page]], specifically that his name is listed in the template as "Pokémon Gold, Silver and Crystal" when it should be "Rocket Executive".  Since the page is protected... yeah, just pointing it out. --<b><font face="Trebuchet MS">[[User:Turaga Dlakii| Dlakii]] <sup><font size="2">([[User talk:Turaga Dlakii|Talk!]])</font></sup></font></b> 10:49, 18 February 2010 (UTC)
+== Whether or not Proton and Petrel existed ==
+Now, I know this has probably been debated before, but... Admittedly, there is more than one male Executive in the original ''G/S/C'', but I really don't think that we can act like Game Freak has had Proton and Petrel designed since those games. Sure, the Executives in their places may have existed, but it's not like those Executives were really intended to be Proton and Petrel all those years ago. Their designs and names originate in ''HG/SS'', and they ought to be treated as though they were created and designed for those games. Indeed, there were Executives who we can say were ''technically'' Proton and Petrel, or just equivalents to them, even if they didn't have their personalities or dialogue as shown in ''HG/SS''. But can we really say that they definitively ''were'' Proton and Petrel, just without names or individual designs? I don't think it ought to be worded like that, since their designs and names have only ever appeared in ''HG/SS'' and we've heard no proof from anyone at Game Freak that they originally intended for all the Executives to be characterized and designed differently as they are in ''HG/SS''.
+Alright, that's my two cents, now someone shoot me down. For some reason, it happens every time I try to bring an argument to the table on a talk page, no matter what wiki I'm on and no matter how much I've thought my argument through. XD [[User:Teamrocketspy621|Teamrocketspy621]] 22:55, 4 April 2010 (UTC)