View source for Talk:It's Super Effective (podcast)

Someone placed a banner disputing the neutrality of this article, calling for discussion on that subject here on the talk page. No one has done that yet, so I thought I would start. I understand the worry, as this has been edited by those who are affiliated with the subject matter (myself included,) but I would hesitate to say it is too far from neutral. However, obviously my opinion is a bit biased. Thoughts on what (if anything) needs changing? I apologize if this isn't protocol for talk pages. I'm new to them.

[[User:Traf12|Traf12]] 17:37, 31 May 2012 (UTC)

I agree, the content on the podcast's bulbapedia page is factualy. Perhaps in the first section that mentions the podcast as "having taken the top Pokémon podcast spot from The Pallet Tribune's WTPT - Pokémon Radio" may seem bias. Maybe this needs to be cited for credibility which will eliminate any percieved bias

[[User:Sprucey|Sprucey]] ([[User talk:Sprucey|talk]]) 04:43, 13 June 2012 (UTC)

Taking the top spot would probably refer to the amount of reviews in iTunes. While WTPT has 159 reviews (with a 4.5 star rating), ISE has 244 reviews (with a 5 star rating). WTPT also has 250+ fans on Facebook, while ISE has over 1400 fans. Finally WTPT has 400 followers on Twitter, while ISE has over 2000. I think those are all good cites for creditability. 

Finally - I disagree with how the awards are hidden. Those can be cited and various other podcasts did compete to win both times. If an artist won a grammy or an oscar, those would be featured on their said Wikipeida. It would be the same here. The "Shorty" awards is a hosted and sponsored event, therefor that sound stand. 

[[User:Committhistomemory|Committhistomemory]] ([[User talk:Committhistomemory|talk]]) 06:25, 14 July 2012 (UTC)

Who can we talk to about what needs to be done on behalf of ISE or Bulbapedia to resolve this?
[[User:GrimmDark|GrimmDark]] ([[User talk:GrimmDark|talk]])