Open main menu

Bulbapedia β

Changes

Talk:Bugsy's Scyther

3,129 bytes added, 03:51, 18 May 2009
Please check this out
:There has been some discussion in the past as to what constitutes notability. I personally believe that the main Pokémon of a gym leader/E4/frontier brain should only get an article if they did more than simply battle. I'm protecting the article until we come to a consensus. --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] <sup>[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]</sup> 20:30, 4 January 2009 (UTC)
::So are we going to delete all of the other one time Gym Leader Pokémon as well? What is the big deal about a Gym Leader having an article on just one of their Pokémon. It's not hurting anything. --[[Tracey Sketchit|<span style="color:#33CC66;">'''ケンジ'''</span>]][[User talk:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#6600CC;">'''の'''</span>]][[User:Kenji-girl|<span style="color:#FF00CC;">'''ガール'''</span>]] 20:34, 4 January 2009 (UTC)
 
:::I believe that these are the rules for notability, I have seen various discussions going on about this lately and I would like to clarify what the real rules are:
 
[[Ash]], [[Misty]], [[Brock]], [[Tracey]], [[May]], [[Max]], [[Dawn]]. If they catch something, it's notable.
 
Any '''real''' Pokémon, Move, Glitch Pokémon, Ability, Location, Song, Episode, COD, Manga, Game, recurring character or Special Chapter is automatically notable.
 
The userspace is notable (as is the User talk space)
 
Templates are all notable if they relate to pokémon.
 
{{tt|Each [[Gym Leader]], [[Elite Four]], [[Frontier Brain]] or [[Rival]] gets a page on their most notable Pokémon|this is the most argued topic}} (that means: '''[[Brock]] ({{p|Onix}}), [[Misty]] ({{p|Psyduck}}), [[Lt. Surge]] ({{p|Raichu}}), [[Erika]] ({{p|Gloom}}), [[Sabrina]] ({{p|Kadabra}}), [[Koga]] ({{p|Venomoth}}), [[Blaine]] ({{p|Magmar}}), [[Giovanni]] ({{p|Persian}}), [[Lorelei]] ({{p|Cloyster}}), [[Bruno]] ({{p|Onix}}),''' [[Agatha]] ({{p|Gengar}}),''' [[Lance]] ({{p|Dragonite}}) ({{p|Gyarados}}), [[Gary]] ({{p|Blastoise}}), [[Falkner]] ({{p|Pidgeot}}), [[Bugsy]] ({{p|Scyther}}), [[Whitney]] ({{p|Miltank}}), [[Morty]] ({{p|Gengar}}), [[Chuck]] ({{p|Machoke}}), [[Jasmine]] ({{p|Ampharos}}), [[Pryce]] ({{p|Piloswine}}), [[Clair]] ({{p|Dragonair}}),''' [[Will]] ({{p|Xatu}}), [[Karen]] ({{p|Umbreon}}),''' [[Roxanne]] ({{p|Nosepass}}), [[Brawly]] ({{p|Hariyama}}), [[Wattson]] ({{p|Manectric}}), [[Flannery]] ({{p|Torkoal}}), [[Norman]] ({{p|Slaking}}), [[Winona]] ({{p|Swellow}}),''' [[Tate and Liza]] ({{p|Lunatone}} and {{p|Solrock}}),''' [[Juan]] ({{p|Milotic}}), [[Wallace]] ({{p|Milotic}}),''' [[Sidney]] ({{p|Absol}}), [[Phoebe]] ({{p|Dusclops}}), [[Glacia]] ({{p|Glalie}}),''' [[Drake]] ({{p|Dragonite}}),''' [[Steven]] ({{p|Aggron}}),''' [[Noland]] ({{p|Articuno}}), [[Tucker]] ({{p|Arcanine}} and {{p|Swampert}}), [[Greta]] ({{p|Medicham}}), [[Spenser]] ({{p|Venusaur}}), [[Anabel]] ({{p|Alakazam}}), [[Brandon]] ({{p|Regirock}}, {{p|Registeel}} and {{p|Regice}}), [[Lucy]] ({{p|Seviper}}), [[Roark]] ({{p|Rampardos}}), [[Gardenia]] ({{p|Turtwig}}), [[Maylene]] ({{p|Lucario}}), [[Crasher Wake]] ({{p|Floatzel}}), [[Fantina]] ({{p|Drifblim}}), [[Byron]] ({{p|Bastiodon}}), [[Candice]] ({{p|Abomasnow}}), [[Volkner]] ({{p|Electivire}}), [[Aaron]] ({{p|Beautifly}}),''' [[Bertha]] ({{p|Rhyperior}}), [[Flint]] ({{p|Magmortar}}),''' [[Lucian]] ({{p|Bronzong}}), [[Cynthia]] ({{p|Garchomp}}),''' [[Thorton]] ({{p|}}), [[Palmer]] ({{p|Dragonite}}), [[Argenta]] ({{p|}}), [[Darach]] ({{p|Houndoom}}), [[Dahlia]] ({{p|Ludicolo}}), '''[[Barry]] ({{p|Empoleon}}).'''
 
Any trainer class is notable
 
{{tt|Please add any comments about my notability chart below|already made things are in bold, why delete these when you can just make more (it's called overachieving instead of destroying)}} You may also want to add the anmu thing--[[Special:Randompage|<font color="Blue">Pokemonguy1</font>]] My talk page <sub>([[Special:Randompage|haha]], no [[User talk:Pokemonguy1|link]] for [[Special:Mypage|you]][[User:Pokemonguy1|)]]</sub> 03:51, 18 May 2009 (UTC)
604
edits