40,987
edits
User talk:Force Fire/Archive 13: Difference between revisions
→Criterion for cross-generational evolution
Force Fire (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 1,289: | Line 1,289: | ||
== Criterion for cross-generational evolution == | == Criterion for cross-generational evolution == | ||
I see that cases like Alolan Exeggutor and Hisuian Typhlosion are added back to the cross-generational evolution families page as well. While I do see the point in having the cases where new species are involved even if the regional lines are completely parallel to the others since those are still cases where a species introduced in an older generation gets new evolutions into new species in some way, having cases where a Pokemon without forms branches into another with forms feels like the same type of practice as having all regional forms unconditionally because of breeding when those are still the same species being involved and in most cases even with the exact same evolutionary methods. It would make more sense to at least require a new species to be involved for entries on that page, especially when the branched evolution page already covers those cases properly. --[[User:Fortranm|Fortranm]] ([[User talk:Fortranm|talk]]) 09:05, 1 January 2023 (UTC) | I see that cases like Alolan Exeggutor and Hisuian Typhlosion are added back to the cross-generational evolution families page as well. While I do see the point in having the cases where new species are involved even if the regional lines are completely parallel to the others since those are still cases where a species introduced in an older generation gets new evolutions into new species in some way, having cases where a Pokemon without forms branches into another with forms feels like the same type of practice as having all regional forms unconditionally because of breeding when those are still the same species being involved and in most cases even with the exact same evolutionary methods. It would make more sense to at least require a new species to be involved for entries on that page, especially when the branched evolution page already covers those cases properly. --[[User:Fortranm|Fortranm]] ([[User talk:Fortranm|talk]]) 09:05, 1 January 2023 (UTC) | ||
:I still think it should count as it is still a cross-generational evolution, it's a Pokemon from one region evolving into a Pokemon is a different form and from another region, regardless of if it's the same species. The design and where they are from makes them count. | |||