User talk:Ataro/Archive 4: Difference between revisions

Me and {{user|CoolPokeGuy}} are in a disagreement with Force Fire about something in regards to the anime. In [[SM117]], Shaymin used what we speculated was Aromatherapy, but since it wasn't stated out loud, Force Fire decided to not acknowledge it as such yet, a common policy for him. So we waited, and in [[SM134]], the move was finally called out and confirmed as Aromatherapy, and when the dub of SM117 aired soon after, the closed captions aired alongside it confirmed the move's identity in that episode too.<br>

But this is where the problem arose: Force Fire now considers SM134 as the move's debut episode, since it was first called out there, and not SM117, even though the closed captions (which are considered as solid enough proof for Bulbapedia) confirm that chronologically, it was first used in SM117. I think that SM117 should be considered as the debut episode, because I think that the chronological order is what should count here, not the order in which the move's name was first mentioned in some way. CPG agrees with me. We've asked help from other admins in solving this problem, but weeks have passed since those help requests were written, and no replies have come out, as far as I'm aware. Could you help? --[[User:FinnishPokéFan92|FinnishPokéFan92]] ([[User talk:FinnishPokéFan92|talk]]) 08:42, 26 September 2019 (UTC)