Talk:List of recurring wild Pokémon (anime): Difference between revisions

:::Truthfully, my query was not over whether Shaymin was relevant enough to deserve its own page and more concerning whether its links to Mallow warrant it having a redirect (ie. from "Shaymin (anime)" to "Mallow's Shaymin") like some other unofficial captures have done in the past. Shaymin doesn't feel much different from [[Misty's Togetic]] and [[Ash's Poipole]], in that in spite of only being with the trainer on temporary grounds, and even within that time not doing very much, it seems much more clearly located to that trainer than other accompanying wild Pokémon who are just sort of their own individual. It's clear that in many episodes Shaymin is there to take the role of a secondary Pokémon for Mallow and appear for her in scenes Tsareena wouldn't be so convenient, much like Sandy did for Lana as Popplio evolved. We've seen Shaymin represent Mallow in events and follow her commands and even take part in things like her "Z Move get!" shot like usually only other team Pokémon do, and just generally have a relationship like a trainer and Pokémon. Even if it's not a very active Pokémon, it feels like it maybe belongs in a different category.[[User:Psi001|Psi001]] ([[User talk:Psi001|talk]]) 14:12, 6 September 2019 (UTC)

::::The problem is that it is not her Pokémon. They've made it very clear she is just babysitting it until it flies away. Yes, it does have a relationship with Mallow, but unlike Togetic, who hatched into Misty's care and was with her for hundreds of episodes, or Poipole, who was put into a Poké Ball, Shaymin is simply here for the ride. And since it is just a wild Pokémon it does not meet any kind of notability for a page nor should it be linked as Mallow's Shaymin, as she doesn't own it.--[[User:Rahl|Rahl]] ([[User talk:Rahl|talk]]) 14:22, 6 September 2019 (UTC)