3
edits
Talk:Leaf (game): Difference between revisions
→The "Green/Leaf" title is REALLY necessary?
Celadonkey (talk | contribs) |
Yagamitaichi (talk | contribs) |
||
| Line 393: | Line 393: | ||
:::::::Wrong, Selene and Elio are only referred to as such in their SM designs, not their USUM designs. All the evidence people brought regarding their names comes from material that refers to material involving SM, not USUM. Also, you have yet to answer how "Leaf" and Green have different designs past their outfits, as they look very similar to one another. [[User:Sinjoh|Sinjoh]] ([[User talk:Sinjoh|talk]]) 12:04, 20 December 2018 (UTC) | :::::::Wrong, Selene and Elio are only referred to as such in their SM designs, not their USUM designs. All the evidence people brought regarding their names comes from material that refers to material involving SM, not USUM. Also, you have yet to answer how "Leaf" and Green have different designs past their outfits, as they look very similar to one another. [[User:Sinjoh|Sinjoh]] ([[User talk:Sinjoh|talk]]) 12:04, 20 December 2018 (UTC) | ||
::::::::Yep, AFAIK the SM designs are the only ones that have been referred to as Elio and Selene. The names Ray and Ailey have been used in prerelease media for USUM. So the case is the same here; why do we need to use different logic for Green? --[[User:Celadonkey|Celadonkey]] 13:43, 20 December 2018 (UTC) | ::::::::Yep, AFAIK the SM designs are the only ones that have been referred to as Elio and Selene. The names Ray and Ailey have been used in prerelease media for USUM. So the case is the same here; why do we need to use different logic for Green? --[[User:Celadonkey|Celadonkey]] 13:43, 20 December 2018 (UTC) | ||
Sorry if i'm getting the whole context wrong, but going by that whole rationale, shouldn't we also apply "Brendan/Landon" to [[Brendan (game)]], since we have the [[Landon (Groundbreakers 41)|Landon]] figure from the TFG? (which is clearly intended to be based off the 'playable' Brendan from Ruby) | |||
Personally, I'm opposed to this whole "Green/Leaf" and "Brendan/Landon" thing. | |||
IMO, '''Green''' should be her main designation for most uses to avoid unneeded convolution. | |||
I don't think insisting on using "Leaf" within the context of FireRed/LeafGreen holds much ground any longer. If we use the internal data to justify that, we'd have to use Terry as [[Blue (game)|Blue]]'s name within the context of FR/LG too. Otherwise "Leaf" is just one of her many default names (as valid as "Fire", "Green", "Red", "Hillary", "June", "Rey", etc) | |||
While figures ARE official and directly based on the games, they're just interpretations, supplementary (and not integral) in nature. | |||
Thus, I think we should only use "Leaf" in sections referring to the Kotobukiya figure, for now. -- [[User:Yagamitaichi|Yagamitaichi]] ([[User talk:Yagamitaichi|talk]]) 02:33, 22 December 2018 (UTC) | |||