Open main menu

Bulbapedia β

Changes

User talk:Gabo 2oo

1,016 bytes added, 06:21, 14 February 2016
Zinnia
::I willl say, I do consider that the best potential evidence against Zinnia having had a daughter. Long story short, though, there's some evidence for and against it, but nothing really conclusive.
::You may have noticed that I've more or less reverted Zinnia's page, and we can absolutely discuss it as much as may be needed. But my basic position is, if there's two separate pieces of consistent evidence, you can't just label that "speculation". That's simply doing it a disservice. [[User:Tiddlywinks|Tiddlywinks]] ([[User talk:Tiddlywinks|talk]]) 05:44, 14 February 2016 (UTC)
:::I actually went and searched for the exact quote as well. I was looking for it since long ago because I've had many discussions about the topic, and that ''is'' some strong evidence against the whole 'late daughter' theory, after all. (It was hard to find until now, because no playthrough features that line: players rarely talk to NPCs after battle.) On the other hand, I never really thought of Zinnia calling Aster "daughter" once as evidence for it, because since many people in real life treat their pets like children, I assumed that'd be true for Pokémon as well. In my honest opinion, that theory is still speculation to me... but I can't deny that tons of people are interpreting it that way, though, so I'm okay with your revision.
:::...That said, the whole line also implies the player character is a teenager, which is pretty weird considering that, according to Bulbapedia, Brendan and May are 12-years old. --[[User:Gabo 2oo|Gabo 2oo]] ([[User talk:Gabo 2oo|talk]]) 06:21, 14 February 2016 (UTC)
2,834
edits