Talk:Brendan (game): Difference between revisions

Talk:Brendan (game) (view source)

Revision as of 23:47, 25 February 2015

2,005 bytes added , 25 February 2015

no edit summary

15avaughn

34

edits

@@ Line 221: / Line 221: @@
 Also, I forgot to note, but yes, based on the examples provided, moves and abilities do in some cases need the disambiguation.  I see the consistency there.  But with Ash's example above, there is only one Ash Ketchum.  Therefore, since there is only one Brendan, and one Lucas, and one Hilbert, for "consistency" they should not be tagged.  [[User:CycloneGU|CycloneGU]] ([[User talk:CycloneGU|talk]]) 19:45, 25 February 2015 (UTC)
+:Adding to what CycloneGU is saying, this doesn't just apply to [[Ash Ketchum]] in the anime character pages. Rather it seems that every anime original character doesn't have "(anime)" added to their name, i.e. [[Jessie]], [[James]], [[Nurse Joy]], [[Officer Jenny]]. So why are the protagonists subject to this? Heck, the gym leaders don't even have disambiguation pages, so why do the protagonists?  (besides the obvious reason why [[Red (game)|Red]] does.) They just have a link to their anime counterpart in the article, if their anime counterpart is important enough to merit an article. Basically, what I'm trying to say is that all character page titles are a mess right now, so if arguing that they need to be consistent like the "(Pokémon)" articles, then that also means that [[Brock]], [[Misty]], [[Cilan]], [[Iris]], and [[Clemont]] should be disambiguation pages, and all gym leaders should have "(game)" appended to them, and that all anime characters should have "(anime)" appended to them. Instead of that, we could follow what the anime character and gym leader pages are doing already and give game characters precedence over anime characters, like having [[May]] be the main game article, and having a "Did you mean?" or Disambiguation at the top of the page, like most Wikipedia articles. As for characters like [[Brendan]], who have no counterparts, there is no problem whatsoever with moving them to their actual name without "(game)" appended. I think those two options are really the only choices, as right now, the protagonists aren't consistent with anything but themselves and [[Blue (game)|Blue]], [[Silver (game)|Silver]], and [[Barry (game)|Barry]]. So we can choose to either make them consistent with the Pokémon articles (which would require doing the same for all other characters), or with the other characters, which would only require moving the protagonists and those rivals. [[User:15avaughn|15avaughn]] ([[User talk:15avaughn|talk]]) 23:47, 25 February 2015 (UTC)
 == Artwork Section Missing Images? ==
 It's been bothering me for a while that, while the artwork of the Contest Spectacular appears in the gallery, other official pieces featuring Brenden are not such as the [http://www.legendarypokemon.net/images/oras/secretbaseart.png Super Secret Bases artwork] and the [http://4.bp.blogspot.com/-ZP0Vvdw8Aps/VE_aMAic0fI/AAAAAAAAgx8/QxXV16AOOZ4/s1600/Pokemon%2BORAS%2B-%2BArte%2B19.jpg Soaring through the Sky one]. The same could be said about May's page as well. Were they deliberately left out for a reason? Also I haven't seen the Team Magma vs. Team Aqua art around on their respective pages (note - [https://static1.e621.net/data/7a/49/7a4989fa876a87ccae6b9af7c72863d6.jpg image 4961 × 3508 size]).  --[[User:Evacino|<span style="color:#A70000">'''evacino'''</span>]][[User talk:Evacino|<span style="color:#0000A7">''' (talk)'''</span>]] 01:34, 23 January 2015 (UTC)