User talk:Chosen/Archive 2: Difference between revisions

No edit summary
Line 379: Line 379:
[[File:Ash Pokémon Heisei Recap.png|thumb|250px]]
[[File:Ash Pokémon Heisei Recap.png|thumb|250px]]
I had a question regarding the Seaking Ash caught in Johto. Like Mimey, it is also included among Ash's Pokémon in the ''Heisei History of Pocket Monsters: From Tuesday to Thursday, and Then Sunday'' special, alongside other "temporary" Pokémon like Beedrill and Raticate. Should it also be considered as one of Ash's "main" Pokémon rather than just a temporary one and be moved from the temporary section to the released section on the Ash Ketchum article? [[User:Satsjoe|Satsjoe]] ([[User talk:Satsjoe|talk]]) 15:08, 27 January 2020 (UTC)
I had a question regarding the Seaking Ash caught in Johto. Like Mimey, it is also included among Ash's Pokémon in the ''Heisei History of Pocket Monsters: From Tuesday to Thursday, and Then Sunday'' special, alongside other "temporary" Pokémon like Beedrill and Raticate. Should it also be considered as one of Ash's "main" Pokémon rather than just a temporary one and be moved from the temporary section to the released section on the Ash Ketchum article? [[User:Satsjoe|Satsjoe]] ([[User talk:Satsjoe|talk]]) 15:08, 27 January 2020 (UTC)
:The Mimey decsicion was made based on multiple pieces of concurrent evidence, as shown in its {{DL|Mimey|trivia}} section. Seaking, however, only has this one screenshot to go on. In addition, Mimey is a recurring Pokémon character whose role has recently been expanded, appearing in a Poké Ball for the first time since its debut, and being used in a battle with Ash. Meanwhile, while Seaking was caught and released in the same episode. - [[User:Chosen|<span style="color:#336799">Chosen</span>]] ([[User talk:Chosen|<span style="color:#000">Talk</span>]]) 15:49, 27 January 2020 (UTC)