User:NinegonMaster/Sprite Comments/Part 2
WARNING!!! THIS PAGE IS IMAGE HEAVY!!!
Sadly I couldn't have the whole thing on one page, due to weight, so I split it up. Here's page 1.
Pokémon | Green | Red/Blue | Yellow | Back | Gold | Silver | Crystal | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Magnemite | Green's screw is much too big, but otherwise these are good. | |||||||
Magneton | Again we have the size problem in Green, but this time it's the whole Pokemon. Good sprites otherwise. | |||||||
Farfetch'd | Oh good lord that Green sprite. R/B is decent, Yellow's a bit wonky, Gen 2 saves it entirely. | |||||||
Doduo | Foot size is off in Green, but fine otherwise. | |||||||
Dodrio | R/B/G is really wonky. Yellow saves it. | |||||||
Seel | Yellow seems slightly off. The rest are fine. | |||||||
Dewgong | Green is a tad off proportion-wise, but the rest of the sprites are good. | |||||||
Grimer | These are all really wonky. | |||||||
Muk | Generally decent. Yellow's slightly off, again. | |||||||
Shellder | R/B/G has the proportional wonkiness that Green!Dewgong does, but the rest are fine. | |||||||
Cloyster | R/B is sideways??? The rest are fine. | |||||||
Gastly | R/B/G just looks like someone spraypainted and slapped a face on it. The rest are fine. | |||||||
Haunter | These are all really good sprites for their time! The backsprite is wonky, though. | |||||||
Gengar | JESUSITO THAT GREEN SPRITE | |||||||
Onix | YELLOW...These are generally good save for that. | |||||||
Drowzee | These are fine. | |||||||
Hypno | That BUCKING Green sprite. Christ. | |||||||
Krabby | Mirroring abuse in R/B/G. Otherwise fine. | |||||||
Kingler | Mirrored again in R/B, otherwise fine. | |||||||
Voltorb | No problems here. | |||||||
Electrode | Why the ring in R/B/G? | |||||||
Exeggcute | HCRISTO THAT HUGE EGG IN R/B | |||||||
Exeggutor | Look at all the wonk in general. | |||||||
Cubone | R/B/G have much wonkiness, and Yellow appears to be missing a neck. Fine otherwise. | |||||||
Marowak | Look at all the wonk in Gen 1. Fine otherwise. | |||||||
Hitmonlee | These are actually pretty good. | |||||||
Hitmonchan | I can't unsee a Togetic and a Doduo in that Green sprite. Decent for the rest of Gen 1, Gen 2 saves it entirely. | |||||||
Lickitung | R/B/G is really weird. The rest are fine, though. | |||||||
Koffing | Go home R/B, you're drunk. Fine otherwise. | |||||||
Weezing | These are all good. | |||||||
Rhyhorn | Goodness gracious alive Gen. 1. Fine otherwise. | |||||||
Rhydon | Green looks too chibi. Fine otherwise. | |||||||
Chansey | What is even happening in Gen 1. Yellow is adorable, Gen 2 is fine. | |||||||
Tangela | Gen 1... | |||||||
Kangaskhan | GEN 1... | |||||||
Horsea | GEN 1. AGAIN. Fine otherwise. | |||||||
Seadra | To be honest, the only one I like here is Yellow. | |||||||
Goldeen | GEN 1 I CAN'T | |||||||
Seaking | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | I just can't anymore with Gen 1 | ||||||
Staryu | Looks like I'm not the only one who can't anymore. Look at Yellow! The rest are fine. | |||||||
Starmie | Yellow's lost the ability to can. The rest are fine. | |||||||
Mr. Mime | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | I think their cheeks are too chubby. | ||||||
Scyther | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | Look around, Eren...at all these wonky-ass Scythers. | ||||||
Jynx | They all seem to be a tad off. | |||||||
Electabuzz | Same as Jynx. | |||||||
Magmar | R/B/G...I just... | |||||||
Pinsir | I can't anymore. R/B/G has made me lose my ability to can. | |||||||
Tauros | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | R/B is...passable. The rest are fine. | ||||||
Magikarp | Yellow can you please just not | |||||||
Gyarados | These are fine. | |||||||
Lapras | Same as Gyarados. I love the R/B sprite, actually. | |||||||
Ditto | Same as Gyarados. | |||||||
Eevee | Look at how pissed it is in Green. Fine otherwise. | |||||||
Vaporeon | Generally good. | |||||||
Jolteon | Same as Vaporeon. Believe me or not I actually really like the Green sprite. | |||||||
Flareon | Same as Vaporeon. | |||||||
Porygon | These are fine. | |||||||
Omanyte | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | Yellow onward is fine. | ||||||
Omastar | LOOK AT IT DANCE :D | |||||||
Kabuto | Gen. I is all weird in some way, but Gen. II is ok. | |||||||
Kabutops | These are ok. | |||||||
Aerodactyl | R/B/G is a tad off, but the rest are fine. I like the Yellow sprite. | |||||||
Snorlax | So...Why the pink shading? | |||||||
Articuno | Generally good. | |||||||
Zapdos | Same as Articuno. | |||||||
Moltres | Really wonky in R/B/G, fine otherwise. | |||||||
Dratini | Until Yelow, something was very wrong. | |||||||
Dragonair | Same as Dratini. | |||||||
Dragonite | JESUSITO THAT GREEN SPRITE. | |||||||
Mewtwo | Gen. 1 is wonky as all hell but Gen 2 is right on the money. | |||||||
Mew | What even happened in Green? |
Aaand that's it.