User:Dolphin2/sprite comments/Part 2
WARNING!!! THIS PAGE IS IMAGE HEAVY!!!
I wanted it to all be on one page, but I had to break it into parts. Oh well, enjoy!
Pokémon | Green | Red/Blue | Yellow | Back | Gold | Silver | Crystal | Conclusion |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Magnemite | These are actually pretty good. | |||||||
Magneton | With the exception of Green being too fat they're all good. | |||||||
Farfetch'd | Horrible until Gen. II | |||||||
Doduo | These are good. | |||||||
Dodrio | Gen. I isn't exactly great, but it's good. | |||||||
Seel | I liked it until Yellow, but Gen. II is tolerable. | |||||||
Dewgong | Gen. I is tollerable, but Gen. II is good. | |||||||
Grimer | Hiddeous, just hiddeous! | |||||||
Muk | Same as Grimer. | |||||||
Shellder | Gen. I was sort of bad, but Gen. II is good. | |||||||
Cloyster | R/B is a little bad, but the rest is good. | |||||||
Gastly | R/B/G are too fuzzy and Yellow is on fire, but Gen. II is good. | |||||||
Haunter | R/B/G are a little weird, but the rest is good. | |||||||
Gengar | Same as Haunter. | |||||||
Onix | These are actually pretty good. | |||||||
Drowzee | R/B/G are a little squinty-eyed, but the rest are ok. Note that most of the good sprites are near the back of the Pokédex. | |||||||
Hypno | The noses are a bit too big in Gen. I, but they fixed it in Gen. II. | |||||||
Krabby | These are actually pretty good. | |||||||
Kingler | I think the ridge is too big, but maybe that's just me. | |||||||
Voltorb | Well of course it's ok, I can draw Voltorb! | |||||||
Electrode | I don't know why, but R/B/G have a ring on the top of them. | |||||||
Exeggcute | R/B have a really big egg and Green is just not right. Yellow onward is good though. | |||||||
Exeggutor | R/B/G have big heads, but the rest are ok. | |||||||
Cubone | Green has a big head, but it's good. | |||||||
Marowak | R/B/G are a little wierd, but the rest are ok. | |||||||
Hitmonlee | These are actually pretty good. | |||||||
Hitmonchan | Same as Hitmonlee. | |||||||
Lickitung | R/B/G is really weird. The rest is ok though. | |||||||
Koffing | It's good despite the fact that R/B is upside-down. | |||||||
Weezing | R/B/G are a little weird but the rest is ok. | |||||||
Rhyhorn | WHAT IS WITH THAT BACK SPRITE?!? R/B/G are weird, but everything else is fine. | |||||||
Rhydon | Gen. I disapoints me. Gen. II is good though. | |||||||
Chansey | R/B/G disappoint me. Yellow onward is fine though. | |||||||
Tangela | It's ok. | |||||||
Kangaskhan | R/B/G and the back sprite are HIDEOUS!!! Everything else is ok though. | |||||||
Horsea | Green is a bit weird, but they're ok. | |||||||
Seadra | Same as Horsea. | |||||||
Goldeen | R/B/G are really wierd, but the rest is ok. | |||||||
Seaking | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | ALL bad. | ||||||
Staryu | Yellow is kind of wierd, but it's ok. | |||||||
Starmie | These are good. | |||||||
Mr. Mime | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | I think their cheeks are too chubby. | ||||||
Scyther | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | They all look kind of wierd to me. | ||||||
Jynx | They're all rather weird. | |||||||
Electabuzz | Same as Jynx. | |||||||
Magmar | Gen. I is really weird, but Gen. II's ok. | |||||||
Pinsir | Hideous until Yellow. | |||||||
Tauros | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | These are fine. | ||||||
Magikarp | Yellow was kindof bad, but the rest are ok. | |||||||
Gyarados | Green has a big mouth, but everything else is ok. | |||||||
Lapras | These are good. | |||||||
Ditto | Same as Lapras | |||||||
Eevee | Green's a little wierd, but the rest are ok | |||||||
Vaporeon | Same as Eevee. | |||||||
Jolteon | Same as Eevee. | |||||||
Flareon | OMG, why are all the Eeveelutions the same as Eevee?!? | |||||||
Porygon | Yellow's a bit weird, but everything else is ok. | |||||||
Omanyte | NO SPRITE AVALIBLE | Yellow onward is fine. | ||||||
Omastar | These are ok. | |||||||
Kabuto | Gen. I is all weird in some way, but Gen. II is ok. | |||||||
Kabutops | These are ok. | |||||||
Aerodactyl | I don't know, it just doesn't seem right. | |||||||
Snorlax | Snorlax should not be pink. Period. | |||||||
Articuno | It's face just doesn't look right. | |||||||
Zapdos | Yellow would be better if we could see more of it's face, but it's ok. | |||||||
Moltres | Yellow got every one's hopes up, only to be smashed by Gen. II... | |||||||
Dratini | Until Yelow, something was very wrong. | |||||||
Dragonair | Same as Dratini. | |||||||
Dragonite | I think it looks too cute, but maybe that's just me. | |||||||
Mewtwo | Gen. I is all weird but Gen. II nailed it. | |||||||
Mew | Green is absolutely hiddeous. Everything else is ok though. |
That's all folks!