203
edits
Talk:Unova: Difference between revisions
→Just throwing this out there
(→Mewtwo Returns: Take it to the forums, don't leave this stuff on here) |
|||
| Line 547: | Line 547: | ||
:::::But I'm not debating the basis of Isshu here. | :::::But I'm not debating the basis of Isshu here. | ||
:::::--[[User:Mackinz|Mackinz of SoulSilver]] 15:12, 3 October 2010 (UTC) | :::::--[[User:Mackinz|Mackinz of SoulSilver]] 15:12, 3 October 2010 (UTC) | ||
::::::Let me get this straight. You admit that Hiun City has many things that New York has, even has a New York theme, but you REFUSE to believe that Isshu is based on New York and are crusading that New York is simply the motif, even going to so far as to assume that the real world and the Pokemon world are interchangeable, when Hoenn has proven they aren't?--[[User:Ryuutakeshi|Ryuutakeshi]] 17:14, 4 October 2010 (UTC) | ::::::Let me get this straight. You admit that Hiun City has many things that New York has, even has a New York theme, but you REFUSE to believe that Isshu is based on New York and are crusading that New York is simply the motif, even going to so far as to assume that the real world and the Pokemon world are interchangeable, when Hoenn has proven they aren't?--[[User:Ryuutakeshi|Ryuutakeshi]] 17:14, 4 October 2010 (UTC) | ||
:::::::Oh, hey Ryuu! Nice to see you on Bulbapedia. | |||
:::::::I refuse to believe things that aren't facts. | |||
:::::::Fact: New York is Isshu's motif. (Confirmed by Junichi Masuda on both Game Freak's official blog and in the interview posted on Nintendo.Co.Jp) | |||
:::::::Assumption: OMFG! That means Isshu is New York! OMG!1! | |||
:::::::Fact: Motif means "theme". | |||
:::::::Fact: Hoenn, when it's basis of Kyushu was confirmed, used the Japanese word for "stage". | |||
:::::::Fact: Isshu, when the interview was first shown in PokePia, was confirmed to use the English word "motif". | |||
:::::::Fact: Basis and Motif mean two separate things. | |||
:::::::Fact: This page used the assumption that Motif means Basis. | |||
:::::::Fact: Motif does not mean Basis. | |||
:::::::My thoughts: If Junichi Masuda used the word "motif" and meant "basis", why wouldn't he use the same word he used when he revealed the basis (stage) of Hoenn to be Kyushu? The fact that he used the English word "motif" should prove he knew what he was talking about. That means that Mr. Masuda meant the word "Motif"! | |||
:::::::So yes, I admit that Huin City has many things New York has. I never denied that Isshu uses New York as a theme. I do deny the assumption that, because Isshu uses New York as a theme, Isshu '''is''' New York. | |||
:::::::Frankly, Ryuu, unless Junichi Masuda comes out and makes a blog saying "Yeah, we used Manhattan as the stage of Isshu", we should keep the facts straight and in the open. The fact is "We used New York as the motif of Isshu". Nothing to be taken any other way. Motif does not mean Model/Basis/Stage. It should not be taken any other way than the definition of Motif. And it should be allowed to discuss Isshu being based somewhere else because we do not have confirmation from Game Freak or Nintendo of where Isshu is based. | |||
:::::::Am I making sense? | |||
:::::::--[[User:Mackinz|Mackinz of SoulSilver]] 18:55, 4 October 2010 (UTC) | |||
==Outdated Notice?== | |||
---- | ---- | ||