Talk:List of Pokémon by Alola Pokédex number (Sun and Moon): Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
Line 18: Line 18:
:::::I just want to pipe up and mention, re:Pokeant, that the UDex renamings appear not to have been discussed at all beyond the initial suggestion, and the move attempt looks like just a rogue user who tried to act when there was no consensus. Therefore, it's unclear whether the EB are even aware of the suggestion, which explains the lengthy wait for approval. I would speculate that it seems likely that the attention garnered by this ADex request will in turn prompt them to act on the UDex pages at a similar time that they act on this one, which they are certainly aware of, given SnorlaxMonster's comment here. [[User:Pumpkinking0192|Pumpkinking0192]] ([[User talk:Pumpkinking0192|talk]]) 05:06, 23 September 2017 (UTC)
:::::I just want to pipe up and mention, re:Pokeant, that the UDex renamings appear not to have been discussed at all beyond the initial suggestion, and the move attempt looks like just a rogue user who tried to act when there was no consensus. Therefore, it's unclear whether the EB are even aware of the suggestion, which explains the lengthy wait for approval. I would speculate that it seems likely that the attention garnered by this ADex request will in turn prompt them to act on the UDex pages at a similar time that they act on this one, which they are certainly aware of, given SnorlaxMonster's comment here. [[User:Pumpkinking0192|Pumpkinking0192]] ([[User talk:Pumpkinking0192|talk]]) 05:06, 23 September 2017 (UTC)
:::::: The thing is that looking through most of the pages in [[:Category:Candidates_for_moving]], either there is no discussion at all, or the discussion only consist of the person who suggested it (in the case of Unova dex, me). (Most of) Those that do have replies won't even last 5 people commenting on it. And the number of talk pages with the admins involved in the discussion is very minimum. And another note is that most of the pages in that category is just sitting there for months with no signs of any work to move or remove them from the page. Im sure the admins know about the page, and most likely have their private discussion but the lack of transparently about what is being discussed in the admin side just makes me wonder if the EB knows.  But like you said, this ADex page will most likely garner attention and will be moved if necessary, but i cant say the same for those others in the category which had been there for months. -[[User:Pokeant|Pokeant]] ([[User talk:Pokeant|talk]]) 06:08, 23 September 2017 (UTC)
:::::: The thing is that looking through most of the pages in [[:Category:Candidates_for_moving]], either there is no discussion at all, or the discussion only consist of the person who suggested it (in the case of Unova dex, me). (Most of) Those that do have replies won't even last 5 people commenting on it. And the number of talk pages with the admins involved in the discussion is very minimum. And another note is that most of the pages in that category is just sitting there for months with no signs of any work to move or remove them from the page. Im sure the admins know about the page, and most likely have their private discussion but the lack of transparently about what is being discussed in the admin side just makes me wonder if the EB knows.  But like you said, this ADex page will most likely garner attention and will be moved if necessary, but i cant say the same for those others in the category which had been there for months. -[[User:Pokeant|Pokeant]] ([[User talk:Pokeant|talk]]) 06:08, 23 September 2017 (UTC)
== Island Dex Numbering ==
It mentions that each island dex keeps the overall Alola Dex numbering - even specifically pointing out that Pikipek is #10 even when it's the first in the dex. This definitely is the case when I check in-game.
But this (and the counterpart page for the USUM Alola dex) doesn't actually do that. It lists Pikipek as #1 for Akala, Ula'Ula, and Poni, and so on. As far as I can tell, this renumbering can only be found on Serebii and here and isn't official; should it be changed?--[[User:Goukazaru|Gou]] ([[User talk:Goukazaru|talk]]) 15:06, 9 January 2018 (UTC)
317

edits