472
edits
Talk:AmourShipping: Difference between revisions
→XY23
Monstarules (talk | contribs) (→XY23) |
(→XY23) |
||
| Line 137: | Line 137: | ||
:In my view, that is almost entirely speculation and reaching pretty far to find points for the sake of adding stuff. Especially on longer ship pages like this one, the point is not to list every little possible hint, but to focus on the main evidence for the ship. Also, unrelated, but I have a decent display on my laptop and that image is humongous. Smaller images are better, no need for something that takes up nearly the whole screen of a full HD 1960x1080 display. [[User:ChE clarinetist|ChE clarinetist]] ([[User talk:ChE clarinetist|talk]]) 05:10, 4 February 2016 (UTC) | :In my view, that is almost entirely speculation and reaching pretty far to find points for the sake of adding stuff. Especially on longer ship pages like this one, the point is not to list every little possible hint, but to focus on the main evidence for the ship. Also, unrelated, but I have a decent display on my laptop and that image is humongous. Smaller images are better, no need for something that takes up nearly the whole screen of a full HD 1960x1080 display. [[User:ChE clarinetist|ChE clarinetist]] ([[User talk:ChE clarinetist|talk]]) 05:10, 4 February 2016 (UTC) | ||
::Well sure, it's why I labeled it as speculation! However, I do disagree with your opinion slightly. While this is a large page, and I don't want to jumble it with nonsense, every bit of tangible evidence helps, and that first one is the one I feel should really be added. I did say that there's not a lot of focus on Ash, but that hint there for Serena (Hint #1) seems like it could be added. Sorry for the huge image by the way, my computer is quite powerful and has a nice monitor :p --[[User:Monstarules|Monstarules]] ([[User talk:Monstarules|talk]]) 15:05, 4 February 2016 (UTC) | ::Well sure, it's why I labeled it as speculation! However, I do disagree with your opinion slightly. While this is a large page, and I don't want to jumble it with nonsense, every bit of tangible evidence helps, and that first one is the one I feel should really be added. I did say that there's not a lot of focus on Ash, but that hint there for Serena (Hint #1) seems like it could be added. Sorry for the huge image by the way, my computer is quite powerful and has a nice monitor :p --[[User:Monstarules|Monstarules]] ([[User talk:Monstarules|talk]]) 15:05, 4 February 2016 (UTC) | ||
:::That is not a hint, as it is not true. That is just the way she is standing slightly behind Ash and her arm is behind him blocked from view. Happens a lot in the anime. And as you said, you labeled it as speculation. While in most cases shipping pages are fan speculation, there is a limit as to how much speculation can be tolerated. If you have to stretch to make something fit, it does not belong on the page. If you have to try to guess a character's thoughts, it does not belong on the page. A lot of what you posted is a long stretch, and does not actually mean anything more than "the animators forgot the positions, or needed to switch them around for the next scene". [[User:ChE clarinetist|ChE clarinetist]] ([[User talk:ChE clarinetist|talk]]) 16:15, 4 February 2016 (UTC) | |||