Talk:Burned Tower: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
(→‎Brass Tower: new section)
No edit summary
Line 43: Line 43:


I can understand why the page was moved to "Burned Tower" (because of [[Bell Tower]], though I think that this one also shouldn't be moved to begin with), it annoys me that the name "Brass Tower" is now just briefly mentioned in the Trivia section, as if it was something meaningless and/or outdated. But this is actually THE PROPER NAME OF THAT TOWER. The fact that the name wasn't mentioned in HGSS does not mean that it's non-canon or out of date. We should use the facts that we know, as long as they're confirmed without any contradiction. I can see why people think that "Bell Tower" and "Brass Tower" don't fit together (again, NoA's stupidity) but it's not a reason to relegate it to the very bottom of the page next to all those unimportant, useless informations. This is still the Tower's real name, as it hasn't always been burned. If some future Johto games (as long as there will be such games, odds are unlikely for now) feature a different name for "Kane-no tou", then we should use it. But for now, we should consider the name "Brass Tower" as the real canon name. I'm not telling to move the page, just give this fact some more attention. It's the same for all other things that weren't referenced in HGSS - this doesn't make them non-canon! --[[User:Maxim|Maxim]] 13:41, 10 May 2010 (UTC)
I can understand why the page was moved to "Burned Tower" (because of [[Bell Tower]], though I think that this one also shouldn't be moved to begin with), it annoys me that the name "Brass Tower" is now just briefly mentioned in the Trivia section, as if it was something meaningless and/or outdated. But this is actually THE PROPER NAME OF THAT TOWER. The fact that the name wasn't mentioned in HGSS does not mean that it's non-canon or out of date. We should use the facts that we know, as long as they're confirmed without any contradiction. I can see why people think that "Bell Tower" and "Brass Tower" don't fit together (again, NoA's stupidity) but it's not a reason to relegate it to the very bottom of the page next to all those unimportant, useless informations. This is still the Tower's real name, as it hasn't always been burned. If some future Johto games (as long as there will be such games, odds are unlikely for now) feature a different name for "Kane-no tou", then we should use it. But for now, we should consider the name "Brass Tower" as the real canon name. I'm not telling to move the page, just give this fact some more attention. It's the same for all other things that weren't referenced in HGSS - this doesn't make them non-canon! --[[User:Maxim|Maxim]] 13:41, 10 May 2010 (UTC)
== "Unsatisfactory" Images ==
This article is categorized in "Articles needing better pictures," however I feel that the images do not need improvement, and the category should be removed. [[User:Pigyman|Pigyman]] 20:19, 30 September 2010 (UTC)
10

edits