Talk:History of the Pokémon world: Difference between revisions

Talk:History of the Pokémon world (view source)

Revision as of 20:34, 19 September 2009

34 bytes added , 19 September 2009

m

→‎Leaf

Crystal Master

53

edits

Revision as of 20:15, 19 September 2009 (view source) Crystal Master (talk \| contribs) m (→‎Leaf) ← Older edit		Revision as of 20:34, 19 September 2009 (view source) Crystal Master (talk \| contribs) m (→‎Leaf) Newer edit →
Line 185:		Line 185:

	::I left Kris there just in case that for whatever reason you consider GSC canon rather than the remakes (which would still mean the Leaf isn't part of continuity).		::I left Kris there just in case that for whatever reason you consider GSC canon rather than the remakes (which would still mean the Leaf isn't part of continuity).
	::And even if you're going to assume that Leaf existed somewhere, the article is still wrong because she can't have had the same story she had in FR/LG. That would mean that ~~she~~ had the same mom, the same house, the same rival and the same events ~~as Red~~, which makes no sense. If she was part of continuity, she would have a different role from Red's, like May and Dawn had in Brendan and Lucas' respective stories. Moreover, the article states that she defeated Green/Blue in the Pokémon League and became the new champion, which can't have happened, considering that Blue/Green states in HG/SS that the trainer who defeated him shortly after he became champion was Red, not Leaf. - [[User:Crystal Master\|Crystal Master]]		::And even if you're going to assume that Leaf existed somewhere, the article is still wrong because she can't have had the same story she had in FR/LG. That would mean that both Red and Leaf had the same mom, the same house, the same rival and the same events within the same continuity, which makes no sense. If she was part of continuity, she would have a different role from Red's, like May and Dawn had in Brendan and Lucas' respective stories. Moreover, the article states that she defeated Green/Blue in the Pokémon League and became the new champion, which can't have happened, considering that Blue/Green states in HG/SS that the trainer who defeated him shortly after he became champion was Red, not Leaf. - [[User:Crystal Master\|Crystal Master]]