Talk:Nacli (Pokémon): Difference between revisions

m
no edit summary
No edit summary
mNo edit summary
Line 27: Line 27:
:Standard policy, basically. Bulbapedia is a site to document things, we do not misrepresent fanon or speculation as official. That's why Origin sections have to use those weird "may be"/"seems to be" kind of languages. That's also why we do not say that Pokémon designs reference other fictional characters or whatever, especially copyrighted ones. Franchises and general works are fine, i think the mods have loosened up on that after the whole Lokix debacle; but generally we do not want Bulbapedia to imply that a Pokémon's design is a copy of or inspired by another copyrighted character. Unless it is explicitly stated by the designer, of course, in which case we can go ahead and cite them (eg. {{p|Vanilluxe}}'s page where [[James Turner]] talked about Stay Puft as an inspiration).
:Standard policy, basically. Bulbapedia is a site to document things, we do not misrepresent fanon or speculation as official. That's why Origin sections have to use those weird "may be"/"seems to be" kind of languages. That's also why we do not say that Pokémon designs reference other fictional characters or whatever, especially copyrighted ones. Franchises and general works are fine, i think the mods have loosened up on that after the whole Lokix debacle; but generally we do not want Bulbapedia to imply that a Pokémon's design is a copy of or inspired by another copyrighted character. Unless it is explicitly stated by the designer, of course, in which case we can go ahead and cite them (eg. {{p|Vanilluxe}}'s page where [[James Turner]] talked about Stay Puft as an inspiration).
:(Also, the page for {{p|Probopass}} does not mention Mario at all in the Origin section, so i frankly have no idea what you're talking about.)
:(Also, the page for {{p|Probopass}} does not mention Mario at all in the Origin section, so i frankly have no idea what you're talking about.)
:[[User:Anzasquiddles|Anzasquiddles]] ([[User talk:Anzasquiddles|talk]]) 19:54, 18 January 2023 (UTC)


:Btw, it's worth mentioning that the designer of the Nacli line, [[Hitoshi Ariga]], explicitly avoided answering any tweets replying to his Nacli design announcement on Twitter, asking if he designed them after Mario or Minecraft or whatever. He just replied "no, this is just salt rock and sedimentary rock" over and over — at least until he got fed up and turned off replies for that announcement tweet.
:Btw, it's worth mentioning that the designer of the Nacli line, [[Hitoshi Ariga]], explicitly avoided answering any tweets replying to his Nacli design announcement on Twitter, asking if he designed them after Mario or Minecraft or whatever. He just replied "no, this is just salt rock and sedimentary rock" over and over — at least until he got fed up and turned off replies for that announcement tweet.
:[[User:Anzasquiddles|Anzasquiddles]] ([[User talk:Anzasquiddles|talk]]) 19:54, 18 January 2023 (UTC)


Yeah because you recently just removed it so that you can claim that I don't know what I'm talking about lol. You really think it's a total coincidence that it's just based on a mushroom rock while bearing a striking resemblance to the Super Mushroom to make a visual pun? C'mon now lmao. Not only that but Naclstack's model is practically identical to the farm animal models used in Minecraft. You're just tip-toeing around the obvious at this point.{{unsigned|Echo&TheBunearymen}}
Yeah because you recently just removed it so that you can claim that I don't know what I'm talking about lol. You really think it's a total coincidence that it's just based on a mushroom rock while bearing a striking resemblance to the Super Mushroom to make a visual pun? C'mon now lmao. Not only that but Naclstack's model is practically identical to the farm animal models used in Minecraft. You're just tip-toeing around the obvious at this point.{{unsigned|Echo&TheBunearymen}}