1,160
edits
Talk:Ash's Pikachu/Archive 2: Difference between revisions
m
→Pikachu's nature: NOT what I meant to write there...
m (→Pikachu's nature: NOT what I meant to write there...) |
|||
| Line 503: | Line 503: | ||
:::1) Tierno's page has Santalune City listed as his hometown, although it was confirmed in the anime, which, by your logic, shouldn't be there, so I'm a bit puzzled as to your using it as an example. | :::1) Tierno's page has Santalune City listed as his hometown, although it was confirmed in the anime, which, by your logic, shouldn't be there, so I'm a bit puzzled as to your using it as an example. | ||
:::2) Because of this, if Ash's Pikachu's nature can't go in the infobox because the event Pikachu wasn't really Ash's Pikachu, then you're basically saying that the anime version of Tierno isn't really Tierno, just some character based on Tierno, which doesn't make very much sense to me. | :::2) Because of this, if Ash's Pikachu's nature can't go in the infobox because the event Pikachu wasn't really Ash's Pikachu, then you're basically saying that the anime version of Tierno isn't really Tierno, just some character based on Tierno, which doesn't make very much sense to me. | ||
:::3) Ash's Pikachu does not exist solely in the anime. Ash's Pikachu has been a character in the manga, has been the player's starter Pokémon in Yellow, and yes, has been an event Pokémon. It's impossible to completely replicate anime Pokémon in the games, but the event Pokémon is still Ash's Pikachu, even if it's not the anime version. As Mikuri said, the infobox comes from the entire article. If the infobox can't include information from the games or manga, then we might as well make pages called "Ash's Pikachu (games)" or "Ash's Pikachu ( | :::3) Ash's Pikachu does not exist solely in the anime. Ash's Pikachu has been a character in the manga, has been the player's starter Pokémon in Yellow, and yes, has been an event Pokémon. It's impossible to completely replicate anime Pokémon in the games, but the event Pokémon is still Ash's Pikachu, even if it's not the anime version. As Mikuri said, the infobox comes from the entire article. If the infobox can't include information from the games or manga, then we might as well make pages called "Ash's Pikachu (games)" or "Ash's Pikachu (manga)". Going back to your Tierno example, the anime version of him is ''based on'' his in-game version, but it's still Tierno. [[User:Aggron989|<span style="color:#858585;">''AGG''</span>]][[User talk:Aggron989|<span style="color:#858585;">''RON''</span>]][[Special:Contributions/Aggron989|<span style="color:#444444;">''989''</span>]] 18:46, 20 May 2015 (UTC) | ||