Talk:Stat-enhancing item: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
No edit summary
Line 94: Line 94:
:The category page loses the helpful table showing what generation each item was introduced during, though. It's also slower to compare them when browsing via the category page (especially on mobile where it's difficult or impossible to have two browser windows open at the same time). The tables are also one of my favourite features of bulbapedia generally. -[[User:Sandrew26|Sandrew26]] ([[User talk:Sandrew26|talk]]) 01:41, 1 March 2021 (UTC)
:The category page loses the helpful table showing what generation each item was introduced during, though. It's also slower to compare them when browsing via the category page (especially on mobile where it's difficult or impossible to have two browser windows open at the same time). The tables are also one of my favourite features of bulbapedia generally. -[[User:Sandrew26|Sandrew26]] ([[User talk:Sandrew26|talk]]) 01:41, 1 March 2021 (UTC)
Because the category page does not have the tables or any images, and because it requires you to click the link to each individual item in order to see their effect, it is significantly less user-friendly than the page proposed for deletion. It is also more convenient to have all item information available at once, as this makes it easier for readers to compare the items without having to open multiple windows. because of these features, this page is significantly more useful to the average user than the category page. I suggest that it not be deleted, unless we plan to take everything on this page and put it on the category page instead. ([[User:AroraLovesWurmple1|AroraLovesWurmple1]] ([[User talk:AroraLovesWurmple1|talk]]) 05:26, 27 March 2022 (UTC))
Because the category page does not have the tables or any images, and because it requires you to click the link to each individual item in order to see their effect, it is significantly less user-friendly than the page proposed for deletion. It is also more convenient to have all item information available at once, as this makes it easier for readers to compare the items without having to open multiple windows. because of these features, this page is significantly more useful to the average user than the category page. I suggest that it not be deleted, unless we plan to take everything on this page and put it on the category page instead. ([[User:AroraLovesWurmple1|AroraLovesWurmple1]] ([[User talk:AroraLovesWurmple1|talk]]) 05:26, 27 March 2022 (UTC))
I personally feel that this should be renamed to "List of stat-enhancing items". Putting a deletion template on this seems extremely pointless, since a LITERAL CATEGORY doesn't have nearly as much information as a list. Plus, it's easier to find. Seems like the template was only put here cuz someone was bored. -[[User:Porygoninfiniti|Porygoninfiniti]] 2-21-23