3,856
edits
Talk:Whirl Cup: Difference between revisions
→Misty's ranking
TardisTybort (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
|||
| Line 53: | Line 53: | ||
Sorry to bring this old discussion up again, but it would be good to get this sorted out once and for all. In the end, I agree with Abcboy that someone will need to watch the Japanese episode to confirm what their rankings are. But I thought I might as well add my thoughts here after watching the Korean dub (which hopefully should be closer to the Japanese episode than the English dub). The Korean dub definitely says Ash vs. Misty is the 2nd round, and that Misty vs. Trinity is the 3rd round. It also says that there are 16 competitors in the 3rd round who are battling to get into quarterfinals. There's absolutely no confusion here, and I doubt there would be any confusion in the Japanese. I know we'll have to end up needing to confirm with the Japanese anyway, but I am in favour of saying Top 16 for Misty and Top 32 for Ash. --[[User:Wowy|<span style="color:green">'''Wowy'''</span>]][[User talk:Wowy|<sub style="color:#ED9121;">'''(토크)'''</sub>]] 03:51, 21 July 2017 (UTC) | Sorry to bring this old discussion up again, but it would be good to get this sorted out once and for all. In the end, I agree with Abcboy that someone will need to watch the Japanese episode to confirm what their rankings are. But I thought I might as well add my thoughts here after watching the Korean dub (which hopefully should be closer to the Japanese episode than the English dub). The Korean dub definitely says Ash vs. Misty is the 2nd round, and that Misty vs. Trinity is the 3rd round. It also says that there are 16 competitors in the 3rd round who are battling to get into quarterfinals. There's absolutely no confusion here, and I doubt there would be any confusion in the Japanese. I know we'll have to end up needing to confirm with the Japanese anyway, but I am in favour of saying Top 16 for Misty and Top 32 for Ash. --[[User:Wowy|<span style="color:green">'''Wowy'''</span>]][[User talk:Wowy|<sub style="color:#ED9121;">'''(토크)'''</sub>]] 03:51, 21 July 2017 (UTC) | ||
: I'm confused by why my edit [https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/w/index.php?title=Whirl_Cup&type=revision&diff=2852893&oldid=2836123 removing a bit claiming Misty placed in the top 4] got reverted considering nothing pointed to in the discussion here over the past four years says anything like that. [[User:TardisTybort|TardisTybort]] ([[User talk:TardisTybort|talk]]) 18:05, 25 September 2018 (UTC) | : I'm confused by why my edit [https://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/w/index.php?title=Whirl_Cup&type=revision&diff=2852893&oldid=2836123 removing a bit claiming Misty placed in the top 4] got reverted considering nothing pointed to in the discussion here over the past four years says anything like that. [[User:TardisTybort|TardisTybort]] ([[User talk:TardisTybort|talk]]) 18:05, 25 September 2018 (UTC) | ||
: I see that this discussion has clearly been going for a while. [[EP215]] and [[EP216]] contain no inconsistencies. Though [[EP217]] does. Misty and Trinity's match is clearly stated to be a Top 16 match, though in this same statement it is mentioned that the winner will go onto the "semi-finals" when it actually should be the "quarter-finals". When Trinity goes up against that Feraligatr Trainer it is mentioned that it is the "second match" for that round, meaning this is likely the "semi finals". On this line of thinking, Trinity went through the quarter finals, but it may not have been shown as both Misty and Ash had been knocked out by this stage. The other thing to note it that the Feraligatr Trainer looks sightly different to the Whirl Cup Winner, and the main difference is their shirts. While the light conditions differ between these two scenes, Trinity's clothing is much the same. Yet Feraligatr Trainer has more of a bluey-green shirt while the winner has a green shirt, what if these two are in fact doppelgangers and thus different people?[[User:PardescanSlowbro|PardescanSlowbro]] ([[User talk:PardescanSlowbro|talk]]) 07:14, 20 April 2019 (UTC) | |||