Bulbapedia:James/Gardenia poll: Difference between revisions

no edit summary
(I'm removing this, because there is ALWAYS a Cacnea, and it's kind of a 'hit this sentence on a n00b's head' point anyway.)
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
This is a petition to see whether [[Gardenia's Cacnea|Cacnea]]'s article should be returned to James's Cacnea or if it should stay Gardenia's Cacnea.
This is a poll to see whether Cacnea's article should at James's Cacnea or Gardenia's Cacnea.


==Reason to keep it as James==
==Reason for James==
*We don't call these [[Jessie's Lickitung|Benny's Lickitung]], [[Brock's Vulpix|Susie's Vulpix]], and [[Ash's Primeape|Anthony's Primeape]].
*We don't call these [[Jessie's Lickitung|Benny's Lickitung]], [[Brock's Vulpix|Susie's Vulpix]], and [[Ash's Primeape|Anthony's Primeape]].
*James and Cacnea have been together for a long time - Cacnea's time on the show was spent as James's Pokémon regardless of the circumstances of it leaving.
*Most of Cacnea's time on the show was spent as James's Pokémon.
*James only gave his Poké Ball to Gardenia. He did not release it the same way [[Paul]] releases his Pokémon.  Cacnea is in a training session much like [[Ash's Charizard]] and [[Ash's Squirtle|Squirtle]].
*James only gave his Poké Ball to Gardenia. He did not release it the same way [[Paul]] releases his Pokémon.  Cacnea is in a training session much like [[Ash's Charizard]] and [[Ash's Squirtle|Squirtle]].


==Reasons to keep it as Gardenia==
==Reasons for Gardenia==
*[[Sabrina's Haunter]], [[Casey's Beedrill]], and [[Ash's Chimchar]].
*[[Sabrina's Haunter]], [[Casey's Beedrill]], and [[Ash's Chimchar]].
*Now that Gardenia owns Cacnea, the term "James's Cacnea" is meaningless, since James doesn't own a Cacnea.


==How to sign the petition?==
==How to sign the petition==
Just put your signature down here.  If you wish put comments down, please go to the [[User talk:Kenji-girl/James's or Gardenia's Cacnea?|talk page]]. '''Do not write comments here'''. Also be sure to write your opinions down on [[Talk:James's Cacnea]].
Just put your signature down here.  If you wish put comments down, please go to the [[Bulbapedia talk:James/Gardenia poll|talk page]]. '''Do not write comments here'''. Also be sure to write your opinions down on [[Talk:James's Cacnea]].


===For James===
===For James===
5,062

edits