Bulbapedia:Manual of style/Manga: Difference between revisions

some clarification and fixing some outdated stuff
(some clarification and fixing some outdated stuff)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Policy|guideline|official}}
{{Policy|guideline|official}}
This is an '''instruction manual''' that addresses the conventions adopted by {{bp|Project Manga}} in writing, titles, articles, and linking [[Pokémon manga]] and its related Articles. If there are any unresolved disputes over what best adheres to the style of this, please contact the {{bp|Project Leader}}, {{u|Zesty Cactus}}.
This is an '''instruction manual''' that addresses the conventions adopted by {{bp|Project Manga}} in writing, titles, articles, and linking [[Pokémon manga]] and its related Articles. If there are any unresolved disputes over what best adheres to the style of this, please contact {{u|Zesty Cactus}}, {{u|Ataro}} or another staff member listed on the Project page.


== General conventions ==
== General conventions ==
* The {{template|Project Manga notice}} should only go on completed articles. Incomplete articles instead are tagged with <code><nowiki>{{stub|Manga}}</nowiki></code>.
* The {{template|Project Manga notice}} should only go on completed articles. Incomplete articles instead are tagged with <code><nowiki>{{stub|Manga}}</nowiki></code>.
* When adding moves used by a Pokémon, please do not add them to either the Pokémon's article or the move's article unless the move was mentioned by name when it appeared in the manga. It is unencyclopedic to guess which move was used, so to avoid this, it is requested that only moves confirmed by name be added. If you are unsure, please contact the project leader or a staff member before adding it to an article.
* When adding moves used by a Pokémon, please do not add them to either the Pokémon's article or the move's article unless the move was mentioned by name when it appeared in the manga. It is unencyclopedic to guess which move was used, so to avoid this, it is requested that only moves confirmed by name be added. If you are unsure, please contact a staff member before adding it to an article.
* Please do not add chapter or round summaries unless you have actually read that chapter or round in a language you understand. Please refrain from adding plot or story information based on the pictures alone as it may result in incorrect or missing information. As Bulbapedia is an encyclopedia, potentially wrong information should never be included.
* Please do not add chapter or round summaries unless you have actually read that chapter or round in a language you understand. Please refrain from adding plot or story information based on the pictures alone as it may result in incorrect or missing information. As Bulbapedia is an encyclopedia, potentially wrong information should never be included.
** This rule does not prohibit contributing scans or other images, publication information, Pokémon appearances, and the like to complement existing facts.
** This rule does not prohibit contributing scans or other images, publication information, Pokémon appearances, and the like to complement existing facts.
Line 14: Line 14:
Manga chapters/rounds should be linked like anime episodes. The title, when available, should be used rather than just linking to the epicode, e.g. ''[[PS001|A Glimpse of the Glow]]'' as opposed to [[PS001]].
Manga chapters/rounds should be linked like anime episodes. The title, when available, should be used rather than just linking to the epicode, e.g. ''[[PS001|A Glimpse of the Glow]]'' as opposed to [[PS001]].


Manga that have been translated into English should be linked by the English name rather than the Japanese name. If it was translated by VIZ Media and Chuang Yi, VIZ Media's title should be used in the link (the Chuang Yi title will still be in the opening sentence alongside VIZ Media's, see below). The same goes for characters with different names in different translations, for example, [[Aibo]] will be linked rather than [[Ataro]].
Manga that have been translated into English should be linked by the English name rather than the Japanese name. If it was translated by more than one English publisher (VIZ Media, Chuang Yi or Shogakukan Asia), VIZ Media's title should be used in the link (the Chuang Yi/Shogakukan Asia title will still be in the opening sentence alongside VIZ Media's, see below). The same goes for characters with different names in different translations, for example, [[Aibo]] will be linked rather than [[Ataro]].


== Volumes ==
== Volumes ==
Line 33: Line 33:
The {{template|VolumePrevNext}} template is to be used at the top of the page for manga volumes. It should have all parameters filled if possible.
The {{template|VolumePrevNext}} template is to be used at the top of the page for manga volumes. It should have all parameters filled if possible.


For the cover image appearing in the main infobox, cover artwork official English translations by [[VIZ Media]] or [[Chuang Yi]] take priority if available. If both VIZ Media and Chuang Yi have published a translation, VIZ Media's cover should be used over Chuang Yi's if available. If no licensed English translation exists or the cover artwork is unavailable, please use the Japanese cover artwork, if available. Only if the Japanese cover artwork is unavailable should a non-English licensed translation's cover artwork be used in the main infobox.
For the cover image appearing in the main infobox, cover artwork official English translations by [[VIZ Media]], [[Chuang Yi]] or [[Shogakukan Asia]] take priority if available. If more than one English publisher has published a translation, VIZ Media's cover should be used over Chuang Yi or Shogakukan Asia's if available. If no licensed English translation exists or the cover artwork is unavailable, please use the Japanese cover artwork, if available. Only if the Japanese cover artwork is unavailable should a non-English licensed translation's cover artwork be used in the main infobox.


In cases where there are multiple editions of a particular volume, such as the first seven volumes of the [[Pokémon Adventures]] manga, the most recent edition's cover will be used in the main infobox. The old edition cover and ISBN should still be included in the Publications information, however.
In cases where there are multiple editions of a particular volume, such as the first seven volumes of the [[Pokémon Adventures]] manga, the most recent edition's cover will be used in the main infobox. The old edition cover and ISBN should still be included in the Publications information, however.


===Publications===
===Publications===
The {{template|publications}} template must be used for cover artwork, publisher and ISBN information. The Japanese, [[VIZ Media]] (when applicable) and [[Chuang Yi]] (when applicable) information is required for a complete article and must be listed in that order. Information about international publications, such as in {{pmin|Germany}} or {{pmin|Italy}} or other countries, is encouraged to be added as well but not required for an article to be considered complete. International publication information should follow after the Japanese and English (when applicable) information and should be listed in alphabetical order by country (e.g. France, Germany, Italy, then Spain).
The {{template|publications}} template must be used for cover artwork, publisher and ISBN information. The Japanese, [[VIZ Media]] (when applicable) and [[Chuang Yi]]/[[Shogakukan Asia]] (when applicable) information is required for a complete article and must be listed in that order. Information about international publications, such as in {{pmin|Germany}} or {{pmin|Italy}} or other countries, is welcome to be added as well but not required for an article to be considered complete. International publication information should follow after the Japanese and English (when applicable) information and should be listed in alphabetical order by country (e.g. France, Germany, Italy, then Spain).


For ISBN numbers, ISBN-10 is preferred over ISBN-13 when available, however, if only the ISBN-13 is known, it is acceptable to be added to the article.
For ISBN numbers, ISBN-10 is preferred over ISBN-13 when available, however, if only the ISBN-13 is known, it is acceptable to be added to the article.
Line 57: Line 57:
'''Valentine Heartbeats''' (Japanese: '''バレンタインでドッキドキ''' ''Excitement of the Valentine'') is the second bonus chapter of the [[Magical Pokémon Journey volume 2|second volume]] of [[Magical Pokémon Journey]].
'''Valentine Heartbeats''' (Japanese: '''バレンタインでドッキドキ''' ''Excitement of the Valentine'') is the second bonus chapter of the [[Magical Pokémon Journey volume 2|second volume]] of [[Magical Pokémon Journey]].


In the case of [[Pokémon Adventures]] rounds from [[PS091]] onward, where both [[VIZ Media]] and [[Chuang Yi]] have separate translations, both names are to be included, with the VIZ Media name listed first. The same treatment of the titles should also be done in the {{template|Chapterinfobox}}, with the VIZ Media title listed first. Example:
In the case of [[Pokémon Adventures]] rounds from [[PS091]] onward, where both [[VIZ Media]] and [[Chuang Yi]]/[[Shogakukan Asia]] have separate translations, both names are to be included, with the VIZ Media name listed first. The same treatment of the titles should also be done in the {{template|Chapterinfobox}}, with the VIZ Media title listed first. Example:


'''{{tt|Murkrow Row|VIZ Media}}''' or '''{{tt|Murkrow Flies|Chuang Yi}}''' (Japanese: '''VS ヤミカラス''' ''VS. {{tt|Yamikarasu|Murkrow}}'') is the 91st round of the [[Pokémon Adventures]] manga and the first round of the {{chap|Gold, Silver & Crystal}}.
'''{{tt|Murkrow Row|VIZ Media}}''' or '''{{tt|Murkrow Flies|Chuang Yi}}''' (Japanese: '''VS ヤミカラス''' ''VS. {{tt|Yamikarasu|Murkrow}}'') is the 91st round of the [[Pokémon Adventures]] manga and the first round of the {{chap|Gold, Silver & Crystal}}.
Line 68: Line 68:


===Infobox===
===Infobox===
Each chapter/round should have the {{template|Chapterinfobox}} template, with as many parameters as possible filled in. The chapter/round's image should be the title page of the chapter, preferably uploaded in .png format if possible. Generally, chapter/round scans are in English when available, though a high-quality Japanese (or other language) scan is also acceptable. It is not neccessary to replace a high-quality Japanese (or other language) scan with an English one, as the quality of the image and artwork is the most important, not the language.
Each chapter/round should have the {{template|Chapterinfobox}} template, with as many parameters as possible filled in. The chapter/round's image should be the title page of the chapter, preferably uploaded in .png format if possible. Generally, chapter/round scans are in English when available, though a high-quality Japanese (or other language) scan is also acceptable. It is not necessary to replace a high-quality Japanese (or other language) scan with an English one, as the quality of the image and artwork is the most important, not the language.


===Content===
===Content===
Line 85: Line 85:


For other human characters that do not appear in any other medium, any main character is notable for their own article, such as [[Hazel]]. Supporting characters that have a significant impact on the plot yet are not classified as main characters also qualify for their own articles, example [[Peanut]]. Similar to {{Bp|Project COD}} for the {{pkmn|anime}}, one-time characters that have a significant impact on the plot count as notable for their own articles, example [[Mimi (EToP)]] or [[Whitney's grandmother]].
For other human characters that do not appear in any other medium, any main character is notable for their own article, such as [[Hazel]]. Supporting characters that have a significant impact on the plot yet are not classified as main characters also qualify for their own articles, example [[Peanut]]. Similar to {{Bp|Project COD}} for the {{pkmn|anime}}, one-time characters that have a significant impact on the plot count as notable for their own articles, example [[Mimi (EToP)]] or [[Whitney's grandmother]].
For publications, all books published in English or Japanese are automatically notable for their own articles. Having said that, most books related to manga are already Japanese in origin, and are simply translated into English or other international languages. Due to this, only one article is needed, and the publication information may all be added to one article (it is not necessary for separate pages for different languages of what is obviously the same book). English-only manga publications are also automatically notable for their own pages, see examples at [[Mysterious Mew]] and [[Pokémon Black and White volume 1]]. In the extremely rare cases of volumes in international languages that are not direct translations, will be approved on a case-by-case basis depending on the significance of the topic. For example, the [[List of Pokémon Black and White volumes (France)|Pokémon Black and White volumes released in France]] are notable for their own articles due to the uniqueness of the format (regular volume length as opposed to VIZ Media's mini-volumes, but based on the magazine version) and also due to high fan interest since some of those rounds were released in volume format in French before they were released in English (and in many cases, before they were released in volumes in Japan). Any questions relating to international language notability must be directed to a staff member involved with the project.


===Notability of Pokémon===
===Notability of Pokémon===
25,688

edits