278
edits
Rosebr10
Joined 23 November 2013
m
→The Shortcomings of Bulbapedia's ProjectVA
mNo edit summary |
|||
| Line 11: | Line 11: | ||
* Reporter (Orange Islands) (EP089): Tara Jayne -> Amy Birnbaum [Reference: Tea Gardner (Yu-Gi-Oh)] | * Reporter (Orange Islands) (EP089): Tara Jayne -> Amy Birnbaum [Reference: Tea Gardner (Yu-Gi-Oh)] | ||
** Reason for error: Overuse of Tara Jayne as designation for med-low voice roles. | ** Reason for error: Overuse of Tara Jayne as designation for med-low voice roles. | ||
* Captain Crook (EP113): Jerry Lobozzo [Reference: Dox (Yu-Gi-Oh) | |||
** Reason for association: Failure to recognize Lobozzo's roles beyond Snubbull and Quackenpoker | |||
* Mayor (EP123): Dan Green | |||
** Reason for association: Lack of knowledge of Green's lighter voices | |||
* Mary (Johto) (EP139): Amy Birnbaum -> Kerry Williams [Reference: Casey, Maisy, Sakura, Temacu, Macy, etc.] | * Mary (Johto) (EP139): Amy Birnbaum -> Kerry Williams [Reference: Casey, Maisy, Sakura, Temacu, Macy, etc.] | ||
** Reason for error: Confusion with DJ Mary | ** Reason for error: Confusion with DJ Mary | ||
* Sylvester (Johto) (EP145): Amy Birnbaum -> Kayzie Rogers [Reference: Joe, Max post-4Kids, etc.] | * Sylvester (Johto) (EP145): Amy Birnbaum -> Kayzie Rogers [Reference: Joe, Max post-4Kids, etc.] | ||
** Reason for error: Confusion caused by similar portrayal of young boy characters as demonstrated by Max | ** Reason for error: Confusion caused by similar portrayal of young boy characters as demonstrated by Max | ||
* Milton (EP159): Eric Stuart -> Maddie Blaustein [Reference: Solomon Moto (Yu-Gi-Oh), James' father, etc.] | |||
** Reason for error: Hiccup between Stuart and Blaustein's lower voices | |||
* Pierre (EP162): Jerry Lobozzo [Reference: Chuck Thorndyke (Sonic X) | |||
** Reason for association: Failure to recognize Lobozzo's roles beyond Snubbull and Quackenpoker | |||
* Annie (EP173): Kerry Williams -> Kayzie Rogers [Reference: Mahri] | |||
** Reason for error: Hiccup between William and Rogers' higher voices; Williams has no other reason to be in the episode, whereas Rogers was already on board as Lulu | |||
* Mickey (EP176): Kayzie Rogers [Reference: Lilian post-4Kids] | * Mickey (EP176): Kayzie Rogers [Reference: Lilian post-4Kids] | ||
** Reason for association: Rogers is also the Beauty Treatment instructor [see below] | ** Reason for association: Rogers is also the Beauty Treatment instructor [see below] | ||
* Ralph (EP176): Dan Green [Reference: Yugi Moto (Yu-Gi-Oh)] | |||
** Reason for association: Lack of knowledge of Green's lighter voices | |||
* Dorian (EP256): Sam Riegel [Reference: Donatello] | * Dorian (EP256): Sam Riegel [Reference: Donatello] | ||
** Reason for association: Still affiliated with 4Kids despite not being credited for the season (due in turn to being in a episode very late in the season) | ** Reason for association: Still affiliated with 4Kids despite not being credited for the season (due in turn to being in a episode very late in the season) | ||
| Line 25: | Line 37: | ||
* Shinji (The Legend of Thunder): Andrew Rannells [Reference: Harley, Len Tao (Shaman King), Noah Kaiba (Yu-Gi-Oh), etc.] | * Shinji (The Legend of Thunder): Andrew Rannells [Reference: Harley, Len Tao (Shaman King), Noah Kaiba (Yu-Gi-Oh), etc.] | ||
** Reason for association: Distinct voice type with very little differentiation between roles | ** Reason for association: Distinct voice type with very little differentiation between roles | ||
-The following are from Seasons 7-8, which offer episode-specific credits- | -The following are from Seasons 7-8, which offer episode-specific credits- | ||
* Natasha (AG041): Amy Birnbaum -> Rebecca Honig [Reference: Vanilla the Rabbit] | * Natasha (AG041): Amy Birnbaum -> Rebecca Honig [Reference: Vanilla the Rabbit, Xander] | ||
** Reason for error: No efforts made to identify her character despite being credited | ** Reason for error: No efforts made to identify her character despite being credited, especially considering that her husky tone isn't too far off from her only boy voice, Xander. | ||
* Juliet (AG042): Bella Hudson -> Rebecca Honig [Reference: Maria Robotnik (Shadow the Hedgehog)] | |||
** Reason for error: Confusion regarding her mature accent; Honig also being credited for the episode | |||
* Victoria Winstrate (AG045): Caroline Lawson -> Caroline Hellman | |||
** Reason for error: Failure to check credits and identify proper alias, causing confusion with Andi Whaley | |||
* Vito Winstrate (AG045): Pete Zarustica -> Todd Garbeil | |||
** Reason for error: Failure to not only check credits for cast (where Zarustica was not listed), but also in identifying Vito's voice actor (Garbeil), whose performance is very similar to Yu-Gi-Oh's Marik and is therefore Jonathan Todd Ross. | |||
* Claire (AG057): Rebecca Honig [Reference: Tikal the Echidna (Sonic X), Maria Robotnik (Shadow the Hedgehog) | * Claire (AG057): Rebecca Honig [Reference: Tikal the Echidna (Sonic X), Maria Robotnik (Shadow the Hedgehog) | ||
** Reason for association: No efforts made to identify her character despite being credited | ** Reason for association: No efforts made to identify her character despite being credited | ||
| Line 44: | Line 58: | ||
* Kimmy Shoney (AG112): Amy Birnbaum -> Lisa Ortiz [Reference: Tony Tony Chopper (One Piece)] | * Kimmy Shoney (AG112): Amy Birnbaum -> Lisa Ortiz [Reference: Tony Tony Chopper (One Piece)] | ||
** Reason for association: No efforts made to identify her character despite being credited | ** Reason for association: No efforts made to identify her character despite being credited | ||
Missing incidentals | Missing incidentals | ||