Talk:James's Cacnea: Difference between revisions

I think that it should stay under Gardenia's Cacnea. It ''is'' Gardenia's Pokémon now (James doesn't have a Cacnea!), so it should be named after Gardenia, who owns it. We don't have [[Ash's Haunter]], it's [[Sabrina's Haunter]], so the argument that it belonged to a main character isn't enough to make it stay as James's Cacnea. --[[User:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">S</span><span style="color: red">h</span><span style="color: brown">i</span><span style="color: red">n</span><span style="color: brown">y</span> <span style="color: red">N</span><span style="color: brown">o</span><span style="color: red">c</span><span style="color: brown">t</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">w</span><span style="color: red">l</span>]]^{[[User talk:Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">T</span><span style="color: red">a</span><span style="color: brown">l</span><span style="color: red">k</span>]] | [[Special:Contributions/Shiny Noctowl|<span style="color: brown">C</span><span style="color: red">o</span><span style="color: brown">n</span><span style="color: red">t</span><span style="color: brown">r</span><span style="color: red">i</span><span style="color:brown">b</span><span style="color: red">s</span>]]}[[Image:Ani164MS.gif]] 12:09, 9 October 2007 (UTC)

:It's only Sabrina's Haunter because Ash owned it for '''one''' episode, and it has never been alluded to again. It is not Benny's Lickitung because he is a [[character of the day]], and we do not have articles about character of the day's Pokémon. Same thing with Ash's Primeape and why it isn't called Anthony's Primeape. James owned Cacnea for well over 200 episodes, and what are the odds of Gardenia appearing with the darn thing ever again? I say move it back, and move protect it so that nobody else can move it. --[[User:PAK Man|PAK Man]] ^{[[User talk:PAK Man|Talk]]} 15:09, 9 October 2007 (UTC)