Talk:Sabrina's Haunter/Archive 1: Difference between revisions

:::@Vuvuzela2010: Users have every right to simply vote without making a message on this talk page, especially if their rationale has already been stated more than once. This talk page is already getting incredibly bogged down with the exact same arguments repeated over and over. However, it would be ideal (but not required) if they at least mention what argument they agree with in their edit summary. As for {{tt|CotD pages|And, no, do not start adding discuss delete, merge, or any similar templates to anything I list here.}}: [[Orville]]{{tt|*|Was more important of a character than its own Pokémon Trainer.}}, [[Puka]], [[Crystal Onix]], [[Pink Butterfree]]{{tt|*|Appeared in a flashback, but that really doesn't count}}, [[Nero]]{{tt|*|Uncaptured, effectively a CotD in its own right.}}, [[Aura Sphere Riolu]]{{tt|*|Riolu was effectively a CotD on its own for a two-parter which had both episodes air on the same day in Japan.}}, arguably {{jo|Silver}}{{tt|*|Silver was effectively a CotD in its own right, albeit for an arc of three consecutive episodes.}} arguably [[Cheryl's Mothim]]{{tt|*|Cheryl was effectively a CotD, albeit for an arc of three consecutive episodes.}}, and arguably [[Riley's Lucario]]{{tt|*|Riley was effectively a CotD, albeit for an arc of two consecutive episodes.}}. One could also argue that [[Sabrina]] is '''not''' equivalent to a CotD, due to her appearance in two ''non-consecutive'' episodes. - [[User:Kogoro|<span style="color:#DA70D6;">'''<span class="sc">Kogoro</span>'''</span>]] '''-''' [[User talk:Kogoro|<span style="color:#FFB6C1;">'''<span class="sc">Talk to me</span>'''</span>]] - 11:27, 3 December 2011 (UTC)

::::A break of one episode hardly counts (they were in the same three-episode arc anyway). As for the examples, Crystal Onix, Silver and Nero (and Orville, I guess) dont count, since they are the COtD's. Same goes for Pink Butterfree, though it's technically more than just a COtD, since it also appeared in Spurt. Riolu and Lucario also appear in the games, and Cheryl was one of Ash's {{tt|companions|temporary}}, with Mothim apparently being her main anime Pokemon. Puka is more or less just a COtD's Pokemon, but it and the Crystal Onix were probably given pages due to being physically different from others of their species. [[User:Vuvuzela2010|<span style="color:#FFFFFF; background-color:#6890F0">'''Vuvuzela2010''']]</span>[[Latios (Pokémon)|<span style="color:red; background-color:#6890F0"> Δ  ]]</span> 13:12, 3 December 2011 (UTC)

===Consensus time===