149
edits
Talk:Pokémon world in relation to the real world: Difference between revisions
Talk:Pokémon world in relation to the real world (view source)
Revision as of 23:21, 17 February 2024
, 17 February→Comprehensive map
| Line 1,062: | Line 1,062: | ||
::::::::I agree with Jump Drive, that if the side/spinoff regions were to have a map, it's best for them to be separate from the main series as the compromise and label it as a speculative map rather than an affirmative/factual map as the main series maps are. Give a description like "this is a map of x showing where the side/spin-off regions are most likely to be". This page is already labeled as speculation, so I think it's viable, only if it's placed on the appropriate section [[Pokémon_world_in_relation_to_the_real_world#In_the_spin-off_games|here]]. | ::::::::I agree with Jump Drive, that if the side/spinoff regions were to have a map, it's best for them to be separate from the main series as the compromise and label it as a speculative map rather than an affirmative/factual map as the main series maps are. Give a description like "this is a map of x showing where the side/spin-off regions are most likely to be". This page is already labeled as speculation, so I think it's viable, only if it's placed on the appropriate section [[Pokémon_world_in_relation_to_the_real_world#In_the_spin-off_games|here]]. | ||
:::::::: To reiterate and summarize my reasoning for a separate map rather than a merged map with all regions on it, is that 1: I think it's best to keep it simple and clear for the reader, to remove/limit the possibility of overlap (looking at the map, part of Almia would be part of Sinnoh and it would be part of Hisui in this map [[File:Hisui.png|200px]]). Future main series regions may overlap with the side/spin-off series. 2: The main series is a separate definitional entity from the side/spinoff regions (whether or not they are referenced). Having them separate would make it clear to a new reader that x region is a main series region. 3. The main series has a more confirmed location than the side/spin off regions. This is not just in its shape, but the culture and buildings etc the main series regions have.[[User:Pipcrew|Pipcrew]] ([[User talk:Pipcrew|talk]]) 08:29, 17 February 2024 (UTC) | :::::::: To reiterate and summarize my reasoning for a separate map rather than a merged map with all regions on it, is that 1: I think it's best to keep it simple and clear for the reader, to remove/limit the possibility of overlap (looking at the map, part of Almia would be part of Sinnoh and it would be part of Hisui in this map [[File:Hisui.png|200px]]). Future main series regions may overlap with the side/spin-off series. 2: The main series is a separate definitional entity from the side/spinoff regions (whether or not they are referenced). Having them separate would make it clear to a new reader that x region is a main series region. 3. The main series has a more confirmed location than the side/spin off regions. This is not just in its shape, but the culture and buildings etc the main series regions have.[[User:Pipcrew|Pipcrew]] ([[User talk:Pipcrew|talk]]) 08:29, 17 February 2024 (UTC) | ||
:::::::::I would also like a separate map with the side series regions, but of course those are more speculative, so I agree with Pipcrew. --[[User:DHP613|<span style="color:#337AFF">'''D'''</span><span style="color:#337AFF">HP</span>]][[User talk:DHP613|<span style="color:#7E7E7E">'''6'''</span><span style="color:#7E7E7E">13</span>]] 23:20, 17 February 2024 (UTC) | |||
== Regarding TCG Holon Region == | == Regarding TCG Holon Region == | ||